Classic yellow cake gets a healthy low carb makeover. And it’s made in miniature so it’s just the right size! Top it all off with a decadent chocolate buttercream for a special treat.
Anybody who knows me knows I can get a little obsessive about things. A little, a lot, you know, what’s the difference? It doesn’t become all-consuming, I can put whatever my little obsession du jour is away in its own compartment and manage to function pretty well. But it stays there, quietly poking and prodding me, reminding me of its existence until I am ready to let it out again. This happens a lot with recipes and recipe ideas. I may be looking you in the eye and chatting about any number of things, the weather, our kids, current events. I may seem completely present in the moment. But really I am mulling over a recipe idea in my head, thinking how to make it work, what ingredients to use, and what I want it to look like. I just can’t help myself.
Such is the case with these adorable low carb mini cakes for two. This first one, a classic yellow cake with chocolate frosting, was so fun to make and so perfectly delicious, I almost immediately embarked on making a second one of a different flavour. And now I am completely obsessed. I am already scheming what flavours I want to do for my third, my fourth, and probably my 18th too. Maybe even a 100th. There is no shortage of ideas here and I am determined to make them all. I hope you join me on my crazy mini cake journey.
I typically make large cakes that feed 12 or more because that’s what bakers do. Go big or go home, right? But I also receive a lot of requests for smaller desserts, ones that feed just one or two people. I confess, I didn’t see the attraction for a long time because if something is delicious, why wouldn’t you want MORE of it? And more and more and more? But then I realized that this is dangerous territory. If you don’t have a large family to feed or an event to go to, a large amount of delicious and very tempting food can lead you astray. It may be low carb if you have a proper serving size, but it’s no longer so if you can’t help but eat half the cake in one go. And I pride myself that my cakes and desserts are so tempting, you are always going to want seconds.
Let me be clear that this is not a mug cake in disguise. I did not cook it in the microwave, I baked it properly in the oven. Although I did my second mini cake, a seriously chocolate-y affair, in our convection/toaster oven, to avoid heating up the whole kitchen. That worked very well too. I used ceramic ramekins of a larger size (4 inches in diameter, 1 cup capacity), similar to these NorPro ramekins, and greased them well with coconut oil spray, and my little layers just fell right out perfectly. You could also use little 4-inch cake pans as well.
Now, I do call this a cake for two but it is rich enough that it could serve three to four. I ate a quarter at a time, topped with a little low carb ice cream, and it was just the right amount for dessert. But the point of these mini cakes is that if you did fall prey to temptation and found yourself eating the whole thing…you really wouldn’t do much damage in the end!
Classic Yellow Cake for Two
Ingredients
Yellow Cake:
- 7 tablespoon almond flour
- 2 tablespoon Swerve Sweetener
- 1 tablespoon unflavored whey protein powder
- ½ teaspoon baking powder
- Pinch salt
- 1 ½ tablespoon butter melted
- 1 large egg
- ¼ teaspoon vanilla extract
Chocolate Frosting:
- 2 tablespoon cocoa powder
- 2 tablespoon melted butter
- 2 tablespoon powdered Swerve Sweetener
- ½ teaspoon vanilla extract
- 2 to 3 tablespoon whipping cream room temperature
Instructions
- Preheat oven (or toaster oven) to 325F and grease 2 4-inch ramekins or mini cake pans.
- In a medium bowl, whisk together the almond flour, sweetener, whey protein powder, baking powder, and salt. Stir in the melted butter, egg, and vanilla until well combined.
- Divide mixture between the ramekins/pans and bake 12 to 15 minutes, until center is set and edges are just golden brown.
- Remove and let cool a few minutes in the pans and then flip out onto a wire rack to cool completely.
Frosting:
- In a medium bowl, beat together the cocoa powder and melted butter. Beat in powdered sweetener and vanilla extract.
- Beat in whipping cream one tablespoon at a time until a spreadable frosting consistency is achieved.
- Place one layer of cake on a small plate and spread the top with about ¼ of the frosting. Top with second layer of cake and spread the remaining frosting all over the top and sides of the cake. Let set in fridge 20 minutes, then get your honey-pie or your friend and dig in!
Notes
Total fat: 39.72g
Calories from fat: 357
Cholesterol: 84mg
Carbohydrate: 9.91g
Total dietary fiber: 4.63g
Protein: 10.91g
Erythritol: 30g
Jen says
Hi Carolyn, love your recipes! I need to make one of these to fit a 9×13. Any idea on what to multiply the measurements by? Thanks!
Carolyn says
It’s really not quite as simple as multiplying upwards…you would end up with too many eggs for a large cake and it won’t be as good. But take the cake from this recipe and use that instead (baking time won’t be as long if you are doing it in 9×13) https://swervesweet.com/recipes/boston-cream-poke-cake/
Then use THIS recipe to frost it. https://alldayidreamaboutfood.com/low-carb-chocolate-frosting/ Depending on whether you are just frosting the top or doing the sides as well, you may need to do 1.5 times the frosting.
Cheryl says
I just made this. Looks great, smells great, the only thing I can’t quite figure out is that both of my layers came out MUCH thinner than yours appear to be in the pictures. I used all the same ingredients you listed in the same quantities. The only thing I can figure is that my unflavored protein powder is different than yours and it didn’t help my batter rise as much? I was kind of bummed about that, but I’ll try it again and see if I can tweak it. Suggestions would be welcome if you have any.
Carolyn says
I’ve used many brands of protein powder and never had that issue. I suspect your baking powder more than the protein powder! Also…how wide are your ramekins?
Cheryl says
Yes, it could be the baking powder. I’ll try replacing it and see if that makes a difference. I used two, 4″ ramekins. Thanks!
Lynnea says
Cake was delicious. Nice and moist. did’t need a long cooling time either…just a few minutes. Couldn’t get the icing quiet right, most likely because i did not want to use cream and could not balance the right amount of almond milk , but maybe next time. But the cake recipe was great. I’m going to double it to make a larger cake for a family desert this fall! I made the brownie cheese cake recipe and it was a big hit and I’m the only low carb person in my family
Shelby Huston says
Can you replace the whey powder with wheat gluten?
Carolyn says
I have no idea, I don’t use wheat gluten.
Daisy Lim says
Hi Carolyn, i wonder whether i can substitue whey protein powder with physillium husk powde. Thanks.
Carolyn says
I am highly doubtful that it will produce light and fluffy cakes. Psyllium tends to make things very heavy and dense. The protein powder here is to make it lighter.
Rochelle says
This was the best cake I’ve had so far! I’m so glad I bought a double pack of Swerve recently! I will DEFINITELY be making this more often!
Katie says
Carolyn do you have a full size cake version of this cake? I’m trying to ketofy a cake that calls for a yellow cake box. I figured using the dry ingredients only would work for a recipe but this is for a full bundt cake. Thanks!
Carolyn says
I don’t have one but was thinking of working on one. That said, this little cake is based on this larger cake recipe and presumably you could use it for your ketofication. Just use vanilla extract in place of the almond extract. https://alldayidreamaboutfood.com/2012/01/almond-crusted-butter-cake-low-carb-and-gluten-free.html
Patti says
What a wonderful cake! Seriously, no one would ever know this is a LCHF. I don’t own the mini baking pans, so I doubled all the ingredients and got 6 cupcakes. I baked them for 18 minutes. The were fantastic!
Jessica says
New to gluten free, been doing low carb for awhile. My question is what other flour could I use besides almond flour? I want to be able to make this for my daughter to take to school parties but her school is a no-nut zone. I live out in the country and sometimes find it hard to find coconut flour. What would you recommend?
Carolyn says
Have you tried sunflower seed flour? The only problem here is that it has a greyish colour and can turn green in reaction to the baking powder so you need to offset that with a tbsp of lemon juice. So it won’t really be yellow…more grey in colour.
Danielle says
Oh my! This is the best keto cake I’ve had tasted. I used egg protein powder, added sugar free chocolate chips and made a crumb topping- yum! Any chance you could modify this recipe for a full size cake?
Thanks so much!
Shayna says
What other comparable sweetener could be used? I’m having trouble finding Swerve locally.
Carolyn says
Any erythritol based sweetener would do.
Shayna says
For both the granulated and powder? Sorry if this seems like a silly question. I just started dating a guy who’s diabetic and I really want to learn how to make foods that he can enjoy and will be healthier for him. This is all new stomping grounds for me.
Carolyn says
If you can find a powdered sweetener, you could use that for both the cake and the frosting. If you can only find granular, some people have good luck powdering the granulated erythritol in a coffee grinder.
To be honest, purchasing them both online is sometimes the best way!
Dianna says
I increased ingredients by 50%and made this into 5 cupcakes. Excellent cake! Didn’t need icing. They are honestly just as good and similar texture to homemade yellow cake with sugar and wheat flour. I should add that I used vanilla whey protein powder since it’s all I had and I didn’t reduce the vanilla since my powder is pretty light tasting. Also baked 18 min at 350 F Thank you for my go-to cupcakes recipe!
Carolyn says
Glad you liked it!
Rhonda says
I made this for my birthday and shared it with a friend! Neither one of us could finish half – it’s that rich. I actually love the cake and decided to double the recipe and make mini cupcakes for my lunches. I do find that almond flour is easier on my tummy than coconut flour so this is a great go-to recipe.
Carolyn says
So glad to hear it!
Vicki says
OH MY GOSH!! Thank you SO much!! I just can’t believe I will be able to make a cake with frosting every once in a while!! What a great treat! I was just wondering if I could use vanilla whey protein powder and cut back on the extract, as I do not have unflavored protein powder?
Carolyn says
That should be fine.
Michelle says
If I don’t have any kind of protien powder, could I just add a little more almond flour?
So happy to see small cake for two :)Thank you for helping all to be kind to our diets 😉
Carolyn says
You can leave it out but I think your cakes may be more dense and not rise as well.
Jodi says
Could I add either a tiny bit of DaVinci sf syrup or a lemon extract to the batter to flavor it?
Carolyn says
Of course…but I have a lemon cake coming soon!
Nickie Bray says
I love this – going to try it tonight. I don’t have small cake pans, but I do have english muffin rounds – they are 3.75 “, so maybe that would work. Going to try them on a pan, and hope the batter does not run out under it. I’ve done several of your chocolate cakes, and they were awesome, but too big for 2 people. I end up eating a whole cake (less hubby’s nibblings) over a week, and that is just not practical.
Still glad to have you, sis! I cannot figure this low-carb thing out on my own.
Carolyn says
Glad to help! I think the batter should be thick enough to work in the rounds but maybe cover the bottoms with tinfoil?
lisa says
Is there a full size cake recipe? This was amazing! By far the best real-cake-like taste and feel!!! I am trying to multiply the ingredients, but thought you may already have one?
Carolyn says
There is not but if you quadruple everything, you’d get a pretty good sized cake. Bake in 8 inch pans, not exactly sure how long but start checking at 15 minutes!
Oana says
The best ever recipe! Now it’s my favorite cake! I;ll use this recipe every time when I’ll have the chance -party,birth anniversary.Thank you!
Carolyn says
So glad you liked it!
Lisa says
Wow! Just wow! I thought I would want the whole thing, but it is so satisfying that just a quarter of the cake was enough. So excited to have this recipe!
Marie says
Also, can I add cocoa powder to the cake baker to make it a chocolate cake or would that wreck it? If yes how much should I add?
Thanks again!
Carolyn says
Not with this recipe. It would require a bit of tweaking. I have a chocolate mini cake coming soon!