Mind-blowing keto brownie cupcakes stuffed with sugar-free peanut butter cups. These brownie cupcakes are so good, no one will ever realize that they are low carb and grain-free. Your friends and family will swoon! And less only 4g net carbs per serving.
You know when you bite into something and you think it might actually be the best thing you ever ate?
These peanut butter cup brownie cupcakes are just like that. One bite and you think Oh my god, where have you been all my life, you amazing dessert? Why have I never had you before?
And then you also think, oh my merciful heavens, how can this decadent treat possibly be keto? Is someone playing a trick on me? Have I accidentally picked up my friend’s dessert instead? Am I losing my ever-loving mind?
Rest assured, dear reader, you are not losing your mind. And you haven’t been tricked or accidentally fallen face first into a plate of forbidden high carb brownie cupcakes.
All is well and you are safe. They really are keto and they really are that amazing. And they are deliciously easy to make, too.
Inspiration for Peanut Butter Cup Brownie Cupcakes
New developments in the keto world have made these glorious keto brownie cupcakes possible.
Not least among them are the new no sugar added treats by Lily’s Sweets. They now make their own peanut butter cups, chocolate covered almonds, and chocolate covered peanuts. And they are all absolutely delicious.
I often make my own keto peanut butter cups and they are wonderful. But while they are pretty simple to make, it’s nice to have someone else do the work for a change. Plus I always see these high carb recipes stuffed with peanut butter cups and they always look so good.
For a while now, I’ve been jealous that they have ready options and I don’t. But now I do. Hooray!
I actually intended to make these brownie cupcakes even easier by using ready-made keto brownie mix by Good Dee’s. But as luck would have it, I actually had the chocolate cake mix in my pantry and not the brownie mix.
Although peanut butter cup stuffed chocolate cupcakes would also be very good, I had rich fudgy brownies in mind and I really really wanted that. So I made the batter for my own keto brownies, which are incredibly easy anyway.
You could do it either way and the results would be amazing. Mine were so good, I thought I’d died and gone to heaven!
Giving Away these Keto Brownie Cupcakes
I loved these keto treats so much that a few of them actually traveled with me all the way to Austin, Texas for KetoCon. I’d made them the day before I went, and I left the bulk of them behind for my kids and husband.
But they were so delicious, I couldn’t bear to leave them all behind. So I squirrelled two away in my carry on and it was so wonderful to have such a delicious treat waiting for me back in my hotel room. They actually traveled surprisingly well!
I do know that the ingredients for these are not available yet for everyone. Lily’s has released their peanut butter cups and I’ve found them in my local Whole Foods, but they aren’t yet available on Amazon.
So I decided to be super generous and send one lucky winner three bags of the peanut butter cups and a bag of Good Dee’s Brownie Mix.
Because I am awesome like that. Scroll down to the giveaway below for full details.
Making Brownie Cupcakes from Scratch
I also realize that some of you may want to make these decadent stuffed brownies from scratch. That is possible too, my friends. Here’s what you would do:
- Make a batch of my low carb peanut butter cups. Let them cool and refrigerate or freeze before adding them to your brownies. You may need to make them a bit smaller so that you can get 15 out of them for the recipe.
- Mix up the keto fudgy brownie batter and follow the directions below for assembly and baking.
- Make the chocolate peanut butter glaze as directed below.
- Eat and be happy!
Definitely more work involved doing it this way but also very tasty!
The Giveaway – Entry and Rules
- Open to US and Canadian Residents only. Must be 18 years of age or older to enter.
- If you are the winner and you live in a really hot location, you and I should discuss when it’s best to send these to you. I really want them to get to you intact and not be a melted mess! We may need to wait until the fall.
- Enter following the directions in the Rafflcopter Widget below. It works best on desktop, FYI, so if you are having trouble on mobile, switch to a full computer.
Want more Keto Brownie Recipes?
Peanut Butter Cheesecake Brownies

Mind-blowing keto brownie cupcakes stuffed with sugar-free peanut butter cups. These brownie cupcakes are so good, no one will ever realize that they are low carb and grain-free. Your friends and family will swoon! And less only 4g net carbs per serving!
- 1 recipe fudgy keto brownies (or you can use a box of keto brownie mix)
- 15 Lily's Peanut Butter Cups
- 3 tbsp creamy peanut butter
- 1 tbsp butter
- 1 ounce unsweetened chocolate
- 1/4 cup powdered Swerve Sweetener
-
Preheat the oven to 350F and line two muffin tins with 15 silicone liners. Parchment also works but not quite as well. (If you don't have more than one muffin pan, you will need to work on batches. You can also used greased 4-ounce ramekins for the remainder).
-
Prepare the brownie batter as directed. Scoop about 1 tablespoon of batter into the bottom of the prepared muffin cups.
-
Take one peanut butter cups and press into the batter. Divide the remaining batter among the muffin cups and spread to cover the peanut butter cups.
-
Bake 20 to 30 minutes, depending on how fudgy you want them. Take them out when they are still a bit wet in the middle for fudgier brownies, or let them bake completely for more cakey brownies. Remove and let cool completely.
-
Place the peanut butter, butter, and chopped chocolate in a microwave safe bowl. Heat on high in 30 second increments, stirring in between, until smooth.
-
Whisk in the powdered sweetener until smooth. Dip the tops of the cooled brownies in the glaze and place on a baking rack until set, about 30 minutes. You can also refrigerate them to set them faster.
Kelly says
These look wonderful. I haven’t tried the Lily’s pb cups so this is an excellent excuse to go buy some!
Pamela Fisk says
I like my brownies fudgey. Yum!
Pam Bradley says
Love peanut butter and chocolate. This should be great.
Nicole says
These absolutely look superb and decadent I must try
Robyn says
You had me at peanut butter cup brownie cupcakes!
I’m giving this recipe 5 stars even before I make a batch because I know they will be delicious.
Every recipe you publish is Keto perfection!
Cheers! 💗
Robyn Harris says
Fudgey or cakey? I would have to say FUDGEY, but I certainly would not refuse cakey. 😊
Cath says
These sound glorious. I can’t wait to attempt them from scratch, I’m not if I’ll be able to share ha!
Donna Houchins says
I’m psychic because I see these in my future!
Perhaps when I travel to Williamsburg in the fall to help keep me on track. Or before. Or both!
Dorinda Hathaway says
I like my brownies either way, thank you very much!
Dawn King says
These look awesome! And to not have to make my own peanut butter cups sounds great. I have a hard time fitting in all the cooking from scratch. I prefer cake-like brownies but won’t turn down these.
Tresa Lovejoy says
I have heard so many good things about Good Dee’s mix. Would love to try it. Lilly’s is sure branching out too saw that they are making chocolate covered nuts plus milk and Semisweet chocolate chips.
Alexci DeJesus says
I definitely like my brownies more on the fudgy side! Can’t wait to try this recipe!
Geri C says
I like them cakey.
Richard T says
I like them either way as long as they’re brownies!
Lavonne says
I like my brownies fudgey. Preferably when someone else bakes them. 😁
Marcia S says
Already a subscriber to your awesome newsletter! Both ways – fudgey or cake-y are my way! Will definitely be making these peanut butter brownie cupcakes. Thanks for the recipe
Sandy Sanger says
These look yummy
Julie Snow says
I like my brownies cakey!
Joanne says
Oh my gosh! I’m drooling! I LOVE a fudgy brownie! I’ve made a lot of Keto desserts in the last five years, but nothing quite as amazing as these look!
Norma Santos says
Fudgy or cakey? Either, they’re brownies!!!!
Stacia says
Fudgey for me!
KATIE KENDRICK says
I like fudgy! And I am so bre to Keto this would be amazing for me!
Heather B says
Definitely fudgy and chewy!
Sarah says
I like mine more on the fudgy side but slightly cake too. Right in the middle! And these look insanely good!! Thank you😘
sandi says
fudgy- gooey, with lots of chocolate
Angela says
I like my brownies more on the fudgy side. More importantly, I love having a treat that travels well!
Betty Sievert says
I love these brownies.
Nancy A. says
These brownies look so delicious! I like my brownies fudgy, soft and gooey! I will definitely be making these!
Kelly D says
I like them fudgy.
Sandra says
Fudgy and chewy!
Barb G says
I like fudgy the most but will eat any and all of them I can find!
Annette says
I don’t really have a preference with brownies. I kinda like them chewy, though. These look decadent!
barbara Norton says
I love fudgy brownies!!
Kelli says
These sound amazing!
Koshie says
I already subscribe1
Amanda W says
I love fudgy brownies. I can’t wait to Try these!
Kim D. says
I like my brownies fudgy.
Cherie Trout says
These look so delicious and not KETO at all. I look forward to making these!
Kelly L Sommers says
Looks so good
Stephanie says
I love fudgey brownies—these look great!
Sophie says
I prefer cakey brownie…, with a hint of mint OR peanut butter… or coconut… or cherry… or…….
Shana says
Fudgy is my favorite
Laura says
Definitely Fudgy!
Esther R. says
These look amazing ! Can’t wait to make them .
Susan says
Fudgie brownies! Have a WF near might have to do road trip! You come up with best recipes for tge not so great bakers!
Charity Sauve says
Fudgey or cakey? Hmm, both are good but I think I prefer somewhere in between, but probably closer to fudgey. 🙂
Thanks for hosting this giveaway! I love all your recipes!
Donna Shuman says
These look amazing. Going to make these for my sister, she loves PB Cups
Donna says
Oh, and I like them fudge
Blaire says
These look awesome! Love all your recipes I’ve made!
Sandra Crabtree says
Fudgey brownies. Mmm.
June Desrochers says
I can’t wait to make these! They look so fudgy and decadent. This made my day, thank you!
Tana Antoine says
I prefer fudgy but I wouldn’t say no to any low carb brownie!
Sandra Pellerin says
These brownies look soo fudgy. I will have to make these.
Christopher Sorel says
oh heck fudgy please and never have put the extra chocolate on top as just swirl in my peanut butter or almond butter. Now have some new ways to try. Thank you and yum
Amy says
I like fudgy brownies.
Serenity says
I like my brownies dense so fudgy it is! These look amazing. Just got my ekb yesterday. May need to print this and add it in.
Connie Cerne says
All day I dream about cakey brownies!
Tabitha says
I like brownies all ways!
Diane says
I subsvribe to your newsletter.
Carrie says
These look amazing!!! Fudgy brownies are life! 😋
Geoffrey Grinnell says
I love my brownies fudgy!!
Diane says
I like cakey brownies. They have lily’s peanut butter cups at my North California Sprouts store so I’ve had a bag of them and the almonds.
Nancy Harrison says
These look amazing! I have found the peanut butter cups on the Netrition website but will also try them from scratch. Thank you for once again feeding my brownie addiction. (in a very good way)
Barbara says
Fudgey! So excited for the recipe and the new products!
Christina says
Thank you for the chance to win these great items. I like fudgy brownies the best.
Catherine C Bast says
Fudgy is best for me. This one is a 5-star winner for sure.
Lori says
These look amazing! Adding this recipe to my growing pile of ones to try!
Karen Johansen says
I like them both ways (Have your cake and eat it too lol)
These would be out of the ballpark Cakey AND fudgy!!!
L Erickson says
Fudgy brownies for me. Would love to make this! Looks so good.
Annamarie V says
I like both! I love the Lily’s peanut butter cups they are so good.
Joy says
These look amazing! I love a fudgey brownie and I know these will be delicious as is everything you create! I already subscriber, and I am so excited that Lily’s is making peanutbutter cups! I hope to be able to find them in stores soon!
Alyssha Holdren says
These look amazing!!! I love a fudgy brownie and this is ten times more decadent than any Keto brownie I’ve ever made. I’m SO excited to make these. I will be making a trip to my local Whole Foods to see if they have these peanut butter cups.
Tory says
Most times cakey, but that’s mood dependent… and I’d NEVER turn down either!
Jessica says
These look delicious. I love fudgy brownies esp with peanut butter!
Christin says
I’ve had the Lily’s peanuts and they are delicious, definitely looking forward to trying the cups!!
Christin says
Oh and definitely fudgey for me!!
Stephanie says
I haven’t heard of Lily’s before! The hardest thing about keto for me has been making everything from scratch, but I have grown to think that I really know what I’m getting if I make it myself, so I’m learning to appreciate it. Plus, it’s so much less expensive…
I’m a fan of brownies, so long as they’re chocolatey. That’s my only real requirement. 😄
I wish I’d read this blog a while back, because I didn’t even know there was a KetoCon! Ah, well. I connected with them, to, so I’ll know about it next year!
Trish says
Thanks. I like my brownies either way.
Spencer says
Love my brownies fudgy!
Anne says
Peanut butter and chocolate! Two of my favorites! These look scrumptious!
Lisa says
Love them fudgy! Will definitely pick up Lily’s new treats and make this new recipe! So happy we can make these amazing desserts now and stay low carb!
Terri Scott says
I like my brownies ANY WAY I CAN GET THEM IF THEY’RE GOOD! I’ve been searching for a very excellent tasting brownie for some time. All I’ve tried just don’t quite fir the bill. these are now on my I must make list!!
allison l Gismondi says
Oh Come to mama! Love Lilly’s chocolates!
Nicole Brockington says
Fudgy or cakey? Fudgy if I have to choose, but you really can’t go wrong with brownies! These look delicious!
Jan Taylor says
I’ve already subscribed to your newsletter. I like brownies any way but I prefer fudgy.
Marla says
Fudgy but heck I will take them anyway I can get them!
Judy Lubking says
Have never had one of Carolyn’s recipes fail. I’ve been following her blog for at least 7 years, and am so thrilled how delicious everything is. I made the biscuits from her breakfast book this morning, and had to walk away as I’ve eaten too many, lol. Am giving this recipe all the stars since I know the recipe will work beautifully. And IMHO, A PB cup in a pudgy brownie is genius.
Judy Lubking says
Hahaha!! Fudgy, not pudgy. D!#* Autocorrect! Eating keto has made me distinctly NOT pudgy…
Ree says
Fudgy brownies!!! No doubt
Patty Mallett says
I used to like cakey, now I think I like fudge-y better! I can’t wait to try these. Peanut butter cups are my kryptonite!
Judy says
I’d love these but will have to wait for shipping if I win as I live in the armpit of America.
Kate says
Glad to see Lily’s is expanding their product line. Now if you could get them to make white chocolate chips my low carb arsenal would be complete.
Carolyn says
I’ve been asking them to make white chocolate FOREVER!
RaeAnne says
Fudgy brownies 100% even better with a peanut butter cup!
Heidi Scribner says
Cakey please!
Valda says
Fudgey for sure
Diane W says
I want to make these!!
Keely says
Cakey all the way!
Chris says
I love them fudgey! Also, which Whole Foods carries the Lily’s peanut butter cups? I live in the Portland area (Troutdale) and just might have to make a special trip to get them. Yummm.
Carolyn says
I found them at the one at 15th and Fremont (but they only carry the dark chocolate) and the one in Hollywood (they carry the whole new line of treats!).
Chris says
Thank you!! I know where I’ll be going this week….
Debi Springer says
I have loved every one of your recipes that I’ve tried. Can’t wait to try these! I prefer fudgy brownies and making these will provide that and hopefully a little of the crispy edges I’ve been missing.
Sheri says
These look amazing! I love your Keto Brownies with the gelatin. Make those all the time.
Christy says
These look amazing! Can’t wait to make these!
Alice says
All of your recipes look SO delicious.
I like my brownies fudgy!
Robyn says
These look delicious!
Lisa L says
My hubby LOVES PB and Brownies! Always a hit!!!
Jackie B says
Years ago, when I was working at a food stand at Disneyland one of our morning prep jobs was trimming and cutting up the giant sheet pans of brownies (sent over from the main kitchen) The call would go out when ever there was an especially fudgy pan and the trimmings would disappear in seconds…so there does seem to be a prevalence of lovers of the fudgy brownies. I am happy with any brownie anytime (especially warm and topped with ice-cream!)
I have been staring longingly at Peanut Butter Cup filled brownies for a few years now… I can’t wait to try your recipe.
Carol Wagner says
These look and sound delish!!!
Melissa E says
These look amazing! I’m a fudgey brownie kind of gal – and peanut butter cups takes it over the top yum!
Holly Rock says
These look so yummy! I ❤️ my brownies kind of fishy and can’t wait to try these! Thank you for all of your efforts and amazing recipes!
Tamara says
Can’t wait to try these new treats! Fudgy is always better!
Kim reed says
I love anything that is peanut butter and then to top it off brownie to. These look so delicious.
Mary C. says
Right now I’d like any kind! Keto for almost 2 months, 18 pounds gone and haven’t cheated once! Your recipes are a life-saver!
Therese Kane says
I love fudgy,chewy brownies!
Sue F says
Fudgy… cakey… doesn’t matter to me, I just like brownies!!!
Twylene Musser says
I’m new to the keto baking world…this would be awesome to win!
Mary Claire says
I like my brownies FUDGY!
Karen says
Love all the recipes I’ve tried. You truly have a wonderful gift
wendy hutton says
I like mine fudgy
Stacey Harris says
Fudgey! When I am craving brownies, that’s the consistency I find myself craving the most!
Michelle says
These look amazing. I can’t wait to try them. I’ see a trip to Whole Foods in my near future to look for the peanut butter cups.
Missy says
Your brownies are amazing! Best brownie recipe I’ve ever made. Fudgey & dense just the way I like them. My only complaint is I want to eat too many! Or I’d like them twice as thick for more fudgey goodness! I omit the chocolate chips & opt for a chocolate glaze.
Evelene B says
I’m a fudgey kind of gal! These must be made! I’m a peanut butter and chocolate fanatic. Thanks for posting these!
Linda says
I’d love to try the recipe. I’ve never used either of these ingredients but they sound delicious!
Joanne Voth says
Oh, these look awesome and I love Lily’s chocolate! Thanks for another great treat.
Jennifer Wood says
These look amazing! All of your recipes are. Can’t wait to try!
Carol says
Love brownies. Preferably FUDGY. Recipe looks delicious. 🙂
Steph says
I like fudgey but I will take cakey 😂
Heather S says
Chocolate and Peanut butter are the world’s perfect food combination! These look amazing and I can’t wait to try the Lilly’s PB cups. I like my brownies fudgy!
Pamela says
Can’t wait to try them!
Christy says
I prefer brownies that are fudgy. Thanks for the chance to win.
Katrina Lavallee says
Fudgy brownies and peanut butter cups are my fave!! So stoked to try these!
Jackie says
Fudgy us my favourite, but I will eat either one!
Rebecca says
Definitely fudgy for me! Bday is coming so I know what I want now!
Terry S says
Fudgy and cakey, depending on the mood. Usually fudgy.
Emily says
Fudgy!
Wendy Mauzeroll says
I definitely have to try these. They look incredible
And I like mine fudgey
Denise Fleetwood says
I like my brownies on the fudgy side! But who would refuse a cakey brownie either! 😉
Dawn says
Has to be figdy brownies for me!!
Stephanie says
These look so delicious! Can’t wait to try the recipe!
Ann miller says
I am so excited to try these. We have loved almost everyone of your recipes! Thank you so much for helping us go sugar free!
Raemie says
Love ‘em fudgey!
Mary Popiel says
Love brownies either way, the chocolate is what counts!!
Michelle Matos says
I love a good fudgie brownie! I am going to try this recipe right away!
Avery Lord says
Fudge all the way!
Monica says
These look and sound amazing! I like a fudgie brownie. Then, you add a peanut butter cup? What?! Ummm!
Sheri says
Fudgy brownies are the best!!! I love that the recipe can go either way or hit a middle ground since my kids all have their own preferences for that!
Beth says
Thank you. I like fudgy brownies best
Nicole Lowe says
I love both cakey and fudgy equally, and the “chocolatier” the better 🙂
Kathy says
Fudgy all the way. Can’t wait to try these!
Jennifer A Villella says
Yummy! I like brownies fudgy. Can’t wait to surprise my daughter with these.
Patsy says
I like my brownies fudgy or cakey! Both delicious!
Margi says
Can’t wait to try these!
Sherry Corson says
I prefer cakey brownies but when it comes to chocolate, who cares!
Stephanie Otis says
I can’t wait to try these! My 2 favorite flavors in one. I will have to find the Lily ‘s peanut butter cups and make your brownies. Thank you for the chance.
Tiara Disney says
I like my brownies fudgy
Stephanie Rodriguez says
These look so fudgy and amazing!
Mary Soliz says
These look incredible!!! I love Fudgey Brownies!!!❤️
Susan says
These sound great!
Patty says
I will be making these tomorrow! I love fudgy brownies. I’ll have to make my own peanut butter cups until I can find the Lily’s brand, but these look awesome!
Carissa says
Fudgy!
Angie says
Definitely fudgy. Thanks for the chance to win, and have a beautiful start to the week!
Loretta Shake says
These look fabulous! Love my brownies fudge!
CINDY KUEHN-GLEASON says
Fudgy!
Elyse Sheppard says
Fudgy is the best!
Amy Oldehoeft says
Fudgy, by far! 🙂 This is such an awesome combination. Cannot wait to try! Thanks for all your hard work on these fabulous recipes!
Karen G. says
Can’t wait to try these, and to find Lily’s PB cups locally. I like my brownies fudgy, but I certainly wouldn’t turn down cake-y! LOL!
candace says
fudgy for sure
Tish says
Love them a little more fudgey but i do love a good moist chocolate cake 💜
Heather Bellman says
Slightly underbaked and fudgy are the best!
Kelly says
Definitely fudgey!!!
Linda says
I like my brownies very cake-y. I can eat more of them.
Anna says
You’re killing me. Fudgy brownies and peanut butter cups are my only two sweet vices. I’ll have to go scratch made, as there are no Lily’s cups near me, but I’m okay with that.
Bridget T says
I like my brownies a cross between fudge-y & cakey. A nice balance makes them taste wonderful. I may lean towards the fudge-y side just a smidge lol. I also enjoy a whipped chocolate frosting on top, or melted Lilly’s chocolate yum!
Cindy Schuster says
These look amazingggg! 😍
Nancy B says
I love your recipes! And my hubs is a peanutbutter and chocolate fiend, so this recipe will make him happy. Thank you for sharing all of your wonderful creations!
Christy A-F says
I Love your fudgy brownie recipes. I made some just today and was in sheer bliss.
lori b says
I like my brownies fudgy and always with frosting! These look so delicious!
Dottie LeBlanc-Overland says
I rather prefer my brownies to be like a “rich” cake.
Lisa H Reed says
Look amazing! I am going to try to make soon! Definitely fudgy.
Hannah H. says
Fudgy!
Ginger Gonsalves says
Can’t go wrong either way! Excited to try these!! My husband keeps sending me your recipes. Need to try. 😂
Mom of 3 great kids says
No contest! Fudgy brownies are BEST!
Terry Phillips says
I like ooey gooey fudgy brownies.
Carolyn, thank you so, SO much for all of your delicious recipes and treats. You’re amazing!
Jillian says
I like my brownies fudgey
Michele Herbert says
I love my brownies fudgy, and can’t wait to try this recipe!
Lori Kaumans says
These look amazing! Thanks for all your hard work on our behalf.
Denise Crawford says
Fudgy or cakey? Both!
Renee Rathbone says
Theses look sooo good! I like my brownies fudgy & these look like they deliver!
nancy fiorenza says
I like mine super fudgy
Bowchic says
I love fudgey brownies, they are the bomb!
Chrys says
I love my brownies! Honestly, cakey or fudgy depends on the day I’m having. The main thing that matters is that they are rich, chocolatey and mine! Thank you!
Beth says
Alrasdy a subscriber to your newsletter. LOVE fudgy brownies
Donna O says
These sound yummy! I’ll have to wait for Amazon to get on the ball bc I live in a food desert! But, I love my brownies fudge and my cake cakey!
Michael Britt says
Brownies are the best when they are fudgy of course! 🙂
Claudia says
I love fudgy brownie (I make your fudgy brownie recipe weekly, no exaggeration) and I love peanut butter, what could be better?! (Well, other than winning the contest, ha ha!)
Fanny says
I like my brownies fudgey as can be!
Anna Jados says
Fudgy and chewy all the way! I cannot wait to make this recipe – these look AMAZING.
jennifer isham says
They look delicious. Can’t wait to make and taste!
Carrie L says
Gotta go cake-y!!!
Amber Brown says
I prefer fudgy … I’ve never made one of your recipes that I didn’t love! Thanks for all you are doing to make it easier on the rest of us!
Whit M says
These sound too good to be true! I will be attempting them from scratch and see how they turn out. I know they will be worth every ounce of effort! Love brownies that are fudgy, or warmed up a little in the microwave.. so good!
patricia says
I am not fussy, I like my brownies any way I can get them ! Thank you.
Jennifer W says
Hoping Lilly’s peanut butter cups are available in my neck of the woods soon! These look so delicious 🤤
Erica B says
What an intriguing combination. I like my brownies dense and on the chewy side. (Is that “fudgy,” technically? I don’t think of fudge as chewy…) Would I refuse a cakey keto brownie? Of course not, and especially not with a nice layer of frosting. But I’m pretty sure the proper term for that dessert is “cake.” 😁
Kristina says
Fudgy!
Leanne Long says
Carolyn you are KILLING ME!! I want to try every recipe you post and all that are in your cookbooks. SO, I have everything to make the peanut butter cups and have that on the list of things to do tomorrow. Now I have to add to that list to make these amazing sounding brownies!
Thanks for all you do.
Kristine Hopkins says
Fudgy brownies are the bomb!
Lisa Somerville says
Love fudgy brownies, can’t wait to try these!
Julie Rowland says
I love my brownies fudgy, I can’t wait to make these. I love the Lily’s PB cups.
Sandie Anderson says
I’m making these in the morning! Can’t wait.
Christalina says
Fudge brownies! This recipe looks awesome and i love Lily’s products too! Thanks!
M. Rauch says
I vote fudgy brownies!
Kristen says
Can’t wait to make these!
Jenny says
I’m already subscribed to your email & it’s totally worth it! I love fudgey brownies & I’d sure love to try out the lilys pnut butter cups!! Either way, these are being made real soon!! Thanks!
Elita says
I love a good FUDGEY brownie! I can’t wait to try this recipe as I already love your keto brownie recipe and with the addition of a peanut butter cup..?! Say whaaaaaat?! You just make me so happy 😃
I’m also STOKED to learn about Lily’s yummy new offerings, I’m already addicted to their bars and mini chocolate chips, soooo glad there’s some new chocolates goodness from this brand! Pretty please send me some to try? Xoxo e
Colleen says
Love my brownies fudgy, looking foward to trying this!
Cheri says
I’m already a subscriber to your newsletter and the proud owner of all your cookbooks. I love my brownies as fudgy as possible. I can’t wait for Lily’s Peanut Butter cups to be available at Amazon.
Cheryl Gates says
Thanks for this chance to try a yummy treat. I like my brownies any way I can get them. Love your cookbooks. I live in AZ so great idea to delay shipping.
Kerry says
I can’t wait to try these!! Every dessert recipe you share I KNOW will turn out and taste like its authentic counterpart. You ROCK Carolyn!!
JUDY WITCHER says
This sounds fabulous and I’d love to win as well.
Sarah Oswald says
I love brownies both ways but if I could only choose one it would be fudgy.
Val says
I can’t wait to try these!! Every recipe I’d made from your blog and cookbooks has been fantastic!!!! Thank you so much for putting so much time and effort into your creations! You are the best!!!
paul schaefer says
already subscribed
Kimmy Ripley says
Definitely, love em rich and fudgy!
Dandi D says
I definitely like mine to be fudgey, with peanut butter drizzled on top!
Jackie M says
OMG!!! These look soooo good! Another yummy recipe from your blog!!!!
Lynn says
Yummy!
Dimitrea says
This recipe looks AMAZING! I love my brownies gooey fudgey!
Natalie says
Fudgy all the way!!!!!!
Jill says
Definitely fudgy brownies! These look amazing!
Paige says
Fudgy is the way to go!!!
Beth Pierce says
Doesn’t get much better than this! I love the combo of chocolate and peanut butter! Excited to give these a try!
manda overturf says
Corner piece all the way.
Eden says
These are SO good!!!
Toni says
These cupcakes are so hard to resist! A huge hit at my house!
Kristyn says
Love that these are keto friendly! They look so fudgy & scrumptious!! The best combination!
April says
Fudgy brownies 100% no question. These are DANGEROUSLY delicious, OMG.
CJ Holt says
:-O Fudgy Peanut-Buttery goodness!!
Jennifer King says
LOVE my brownies fudgy!! I can’t wait to try these with peanut butter!!
Grace says
Yummy!!
Shayla says
I love my brownies fudgy! Of course the perfect brownie is served in a skillet with vanilla ice cream and caramel drizzle! I can dream, right?!
Megan says
I love a good fishy brownie. And with a PB cup, even better!
Melanie Sanders says
I like my brownies cakey on the outside and slightly fudgy on the inside. Can’t wait to try these!!
Monique L.S. says
Yes and yes. I like brownies any which way. They are all delicious!
Aleksandra Gawlik says
Fudgey please.
Teresa VanDoorn says
I can’t wait to try these!! I LOVE my brownies fudgy!
Liz says
I like my brownies fudgy!!
Cindy L Trump says
I like my brownies raw, cakey or fudgy.
Sarah says
Cant wait to try these
Alana Jones says
I love my brownies cakey! Thank
Kathleen says
Hi Carolyn! I just saw this contest on your Facebook page! Yum! I like my brownies any way they are fixed, but Fudgy with a crust, are my favorite.
Kathy-Jo Pickering says
My favourite flavour combination! Fudgy brownies all the way!
Julie Pruski says
This looks soooo yummy! I can’t wait to get your cookbooks!💕
Joy Tomlinson says
Carolyn, these look over the top delectable! I cannot wait to try these! Thank you so much for bringing us your wonderful, awesome creations! ❤️
Ileana says
Love anything peanut butter! Fudge consistency is my favorite
Jaime says
I would say fudgy!
Carolyn Johnson says
These look so good! I like my brownies fudgey. I’ve only ventured out as far as avocado brownies so far, will have to try your recipe.
Kay Lynn says
I prefer fudgy brownies. These should look yummy!
Alese says
These look amazing! Is there a way I could make these without buying the peanut butter cups?
Carolyn says
Yes, I was quite specific about that in the blog post.
Alysia says
These polo ok amazing! I love my brownies fudge-y!
Sarah Butler says
Fudgy brownies are the best. I can’t wait to try!
Mya Murphy says
I’ve never met a brownie yet that I didn’t absolutely fall in love with.. Fudgey cakey.. Just the batter..yummmo!! I love everything brownies!! 💜
Pam says
OMG…th se look AMAZING!
Pam says
The fudgier the better!
Victoria Arriero says
Chocolate and peanut butter!!!!
Cassandra D says
I like the fudge type texture.
V Lamb says
I like both but the fudgy kind may have a slight edge.
Terrie says
I can’t rate the recipe yet. Because I haven’t tried it, what I can say is that I can’t wait to make it!! Looks and sounds like heaven! I’ve made two of your recipes for dinner today. I have yet to find a recipe of yours I don’t like. YUMM!! Thank you!
Jodi Thiessen says
Fudgey! Love em both ways though!