These keto carmelitas are going to blow your mind. Heavenly low carb “oatmeal” bars filled with sugar-free caramel and chocolate. Hard to believe this grain-free treat isn’t made with oats!
The first time I ever tried carmelitas, I may have swooned and fallen to the floor. I am not exactly sure where I was, but if recollection serves me properly, I was visiting my sister in law in Bar Harbor, Maine. It’s possible that she made them herself (she’s quite a good cook and her last name is Baker, after all) or she may have picked them up at one of the local bakeries.
Usually I remember details like this very well but I do believe I was so overcome by the delicious, oat-y, caramel-y, chocolate-y crumbliness in my mouth, all other senses faded away. I was transported. I was in my own little world, savouring every morsel, every crumb, unable to think beyond the sweetness in my mouth. I was in deep. Way over my head.
What are Carmelitas?
If you’ve never had a carmelita, let me tell you a little bit about them.
Conventional carmelitas are made with a crumbly oat and brown sugar crust, and are filled with caramel sauce and chocolate chips, with a top layer of the same crust. Can you see why I fell so hard and fast in love with them? I do love oats in baked goods, the way they make things so crumbly and delicious.
I miss oats, I miss them a lot. But I don’t miss them enough to actually eat them and mess with my blood sugar. Oats are lovely but they are not lovely for me. And presumably not for you either, since you are reading a low carb, grain-free food blog.
So is it sacrilege to make carmelitas without oats? And how to get that crumbly quality, the sort that has little bits falling off as you cut them? The little crumbly bits are sometimes the best part. How they fall back into the pan or onto your plate, and you lick the tips of your fingers to press into them and lift them into your mouth.
Exactly how does one achieve that perfect crumble without grains?
How to Make Low Carb Carmelitas
Oh ye of little faith. I am nothing if not resourceful when it comes to low carb baking. And I have come up with the best keto replacement for oats.
There was a time when I needed shredded coconut but I only had flaked. So I popped that stuff in my food processor to chop it up more finely. I noticed an oatmeal-like texture to the item I was baking, so I filed that little tidbit away in my brain for future use.
When I decided to tackle low carb carmelitas, I used both flaked coconut and some sliced almonds. I processed them just enough so that they resembled oats in size, and added them to my crust mixture. Um, not to brag or anything but…NAILED IT! Look at that topping…doesn’t that look like oats to you?
Now all you have to do is add some butter, some almond flour, some low carb sweetener, and a little bit of coconut flour to make it even more dry and crumbly and you’ve got yourself the perfect keto “oatmeal” crust.
But you don’t stop there. Oh no. You go and make my amazing keto caramel sauce. Go on, just make it! You won’t regret it for a second. You will want to just spoon that sauce straight into your mouth. But be sure to save enough for your low carb carmelitas!
Now that you have all the pieces of the puzzle, you can put together your carmelitas. Put down a first layer of the crust and press it firmly into the pan. Then sprinkle with some sugar free chocolate chips. You could also chop up a low carb chocolate bar or even use my homemade sugar free chocolate chips. They would work perfectly here.
Pour your keto caramel sauce over that and sprinkle with the remaining oatmeal crust. And bake it until golden brown. Voila!
These are just as heavenly as the high carb carmelitas of my memory. I am so happy. SO HAPPY! Now go make them and you can do the happy dance with me.
Other Delicious Keto Bar Recipes
Low Carb Coconut Macadamia Bars
Carmelitas
Ingredients
Crust:
- 1 cup flaked unsweetened coconut
- ¾ cup sliced almonds
- 1 cup almond flour
- ½ cup Swerve Sweetener
- 3 tablespoon coconut flour divided
- ½ teaspoon baking soda
- ½ teaspoon salt
- ½ cup butter melted
Filling:
- 1 Sugar-Free Caramel Sauce (leave out the additional water)
- ½ cup Lily's Sugar-Free Chocolate Chips or other low carb chocolate
Instructions
Crust:
- Preheat oven to 325F and grease a 9x9 inch square pan (can also use 8x8 but baking time will be longer).
- In a food processor, combine coconut and sliced almond. Pulse until the pieces are broken up and about the size of oats in size. Transfer to a large bowl.
- Add the almond flour, sweetener, 2 tablespoon coconut flour, baking soda, and salt. Stir in melted butter until mixture resembles coarse crumbs.
- Press a little more than half of the mixture firmly into the bottom of prepared baking pan (it doesn't look like it will be enough, but it is...just keep pressing it in, as thinly as you need to). Bake 10 minutes, until puffed and edges are just golden brown. Remove and let cool completely.
- Add the remaining tablespoon of coconut flour to the remaining crust ingredients and mix well to help make it drier and crumblier. Break it up into small crumbs.
Filling:
- While bottom crust is cooling, make the caramel sauce and let it cool 10 minutes or so. Then pour the caramel sauce over the crust and sprinkle with chocolate chips.
- Sprinkle filling with remaining crust and press lightly to adhere. Bake another 15 to 20 minutes, until top crust is golden brown.
- Remove and let cool completely before cutting into squares.
Nicole says
I made Carmelitas once again and they satisfied my sweet tooth while everyone else was eating sugary cookies I made such as butterfudge squares. It is a recipe that has been in my family for a long time. The base is similar to the Carmelitas so I made an extra base to try butterfudge squares low carb as it’s just the topping and the icing after that. I’d love to send you the recipe if you’re interested in trying another cookie. All your recipes are great and saved me at Christmas when the temptation was very strong to eat sugar. Thank you again for your work and I love your blog!
Carolyn says
Sure, please send it to alldayidreamaboutfood@gmail.com
Melinda says
I am SO doing the happy dance with you! I have loved carmelitas for probably 30 years; they were always one of our special occasion, holiday treats. Like you, oats are the one thing (well, besides pizza), that I really miss with our transition to low carb high fat eating. I am beyond thrilled that you’ve shared this recipe! I can’t wait to try them!!!
Nanci says
I have these in the oven, and I admit, I’m nervous. My caramel sauce did not thicken. I mean, it’s thicker than water but it’s thinner than the thin batter from a box cake mix when you pour it out. It did spread out over all of the crust, though, which it probably wouldn’t have if it had been thicker. Was it supposed to thicken?
Linda says
Would this recipe work minus the flaked coconut? Is there something else that would need to be substituted for it?
Nicole says
These are my favorite dessert now…ty so much…I keep them in the fridge to keep them together…love love love!!!
Nita Folkers says
I made them today! Super yummy but they fell apart?. How do I get them to stay together?
Carolyn says
Grind your nuts and coconut a bit more.
Carolyn says
But keep in mind that carmelitas are supposed to be crumbly.
Karen Ortega says
I have been trying a few of your recipes and this one is one of my favorites next to the Brownie Cheesecake. The caramel sauce so amazing that one would not know that it is low carb. I doubled the caramel sauce recipe since I had a half stick of melted butter already and I’m glad I made a double batch since I will be making a second Carmelita recipe once this one is devoured. I hate trying recipes using very expensive ingredients just to have them be inedible but your recipes are manageable and taste fantastic! Thanks for your hard work and generosity in sharing your recipes!
Dodi says
HELP! What am I doing wrong? I have baked for decades and have never had issues like this. I have tried making the caramel sauce twice. I am using erythritol – is that my problem? The first time I used the molasses and it immediately burned. The second time I used all erythritol, and it was looking OK but suddenly turned and burned. I cooked on lower than medium gas flame and stirred constantly with heat-resistant spatula. I suppose it is the sugar substitute. I thought erythritol was the same as Swerve…apparently Swerve is a mixture of erythritol and oligosaccharides . Ugh. Now I have a cooked bottom crust, Lily chocolate chips, uncooked crumbs for the top, and two batches of the burned butter and erythritol in a smelly kitchen.
Suggestions on what to do with my ingredients?
Carolyn says
Can you whip up some cream cheese with sweetener and cream and pour it over the crust? That would be tasty. Top with the other crust material and bake until the cream cheese seems mostly set. As for the burning…what pan are you using? That could be part of it. Obviously yours seems to burn more easily so definitely reduce the time next time.
Dudley Shumate says
These are the BEST low carb treat I have made to date. That’s saying something. I can’t wait to make again, that’s DEFINITELY saying something! I added 1 tsp of cinnamon to the crumb mixture and used walnuts/pecans v almonds. They are fabulous!
Carolyn says
So glad it worked out for you.
Frieda says
Thank you! Thank you! Thank you for this recipe ! They are devine. Every bite is a mouthful of joy.
Carolyn says
So glad you like them.!
Tom says
I thought these were okay, I used the molasses option in the caramel sauce and felt it gave it a slightly bitter taste I didn’t care for. And I’m sure I did not burn it. The bars are pretty good, just not my favorite type of dessert. My partner, however, went crazy for them, says they remind him of baklava, which I can see in a way.
LuAnne says
I made these today and they are yummy! I didn’t have coconut sugar for the caramel sauce so I used black strap molasses and I think that, along with the unsweetened chocolate, made them a bit more bitterness than I would prefer but still delicious. I’ll definitely be making them again but next time I’ll make sure to get some coconut sugar beforehand and maybe use 85 or 90% chocolate. They definitely satisfy my sweet tooth so thank you!
Jill says
Has anyone tried making with a sub for Swerve? Swerve hasn’t been available in my area for a couple weeks and it’s on backorder through Amazon, ugh. Would love to make these soon. Thank you!
Carolyn says
I think you could do this with plain erythritol and a little stevia.
Tanya Payne says
Tried these the weekend before last and they are outstanding!!
Michelle Smith says
Quick question: I noticed that several of your recipes use almond flour and coconut flour. Could I replace the almond flour with an equal amount of coconut flour or is there something else you would suggest? I have 2 family members with severe nut allergies (we avoid nuts of all varieties). Thanks so much!
Carolyn says
No you absolutely can’t swap them in for each other in the same amounts. They are very different creatures. For almond flour, I would suggest actually using sunflower seed flour. https://alldayidreamaboutfood.com/2015/12/how-to-make-your-own-sunflower-seed-flour.html
Kerry says
Does anyone have the adjusted cooking time for an 8×8 pan? I’m making a double recipe, so maybe even a 9×13?
Thanks!
Carolyn says
9×13 is a little less than double in terms of square inches so I suspect it will need a bit longer time.
Susie says
I just ran out of almond flour, could I sub coconut flour and use 1/4 the amount? Thanks!
Nicole says
Yes, too bad dates aren’t low carb. Lol. These Carmelitas didn’t even last an afternoon and I’ve been asked to make them again so I’m making more this afternoon. I ran out of Lilly chocolate chips. Is there anything else I could use like a 90% cocoa bar?
Carolyn says
Yes, any chocolate would be fine here.
Nicole says
Omg!!!!!!!! I made these for myself and a friend of mine and they were ahhhhhmazing!!! Everything worked out perfectly and the consistency of the crumble reminds of date squares that I miss soooo much. These are to die for and the caramel sauce was sooo good! Thank you again Carolyn for all your hard work! I also have the s’mores in the fridge waiting to firm up.
Carolyn says
Date squares, yes! My mother used to make those. If only I could make dates low carb…
Janet says
OMG!! You have done it once again! These are delicious…not knowing what a Carmelita was I made these anyway, knowing that with those delicious ingredients, how could I go wrong? To me they taste like a “Magic Cookie Bar” from the back of the can of Eagle sweetened condensed milk. Love them but love these more since I can have them on my WOE!!!! Thanks for all you do to develop these wonderful recipes that keep my daughter and me on our low carb pathway.