Low carb caramel sauce is ooey, it’s gooey and it stays pourable! Best of all, it tastes just like real caramel sauce. This is the only low carb, sugar-free caramel sauce recipe you will ever need.
Creating a really good, true-to-life caramel sauce with erythritol has been one of my low carb goals for a long time now. Almost from the first moment I started baking and cooking low carb, I found myself wondering if it was possible and absolutely determined to find out.
Creating Sugar-Free Caramel Sauce
I’d tried a few store-bought sugar-free caramel sauces and they were simply awful. They were laden with chemicals and they tasted like it too! So I had to find a way to make homemade sugar-free caramel sauce from scratch, and I set my sights high.
It had to be:
- gooey
- smooth
- taste great – it had to have that wonderful caramelized-sugar taste
- not harden and recrystallize upon cooling.
Anyone who has ever worked with erythritol-based sweeteners will know that the last issue was the biggest challenge to overcome. I’ve made some great-tasting and great-looking sauces along the way, but they all had a tendency to harden up pretty quickly.
This low carb caramel sauce recipe, however, is by far the best I’ve developed. I’d say it’s almost perfect. Why “almost”? Because although it doesn’t become rock hard as it cools, it does solidify a bit and get a slightly grainy texture. But in all other respects, it’s absolutely perfect. It is smooth, gooey, pourable and best of all, this sugar-free caramel truly tastes caramel sauce made with refined sugar.
Put away all those awful store-bought, chemical-laden sugar-free caramel sauces because this low carb caramel sauce recipe will blow your caramel-loving mind.
I’ve actually been using this caramel sauce recipe in many of my other dessert recipes for a while now, like my maple pecan pie. But I use it so often and found myself rewriting it so frequently, I decided that it needed to be a stand alone recipe.
Believe me, it deserves it! It’s been a part of some of my favorite recipes and I suspect it will be part of many more to come. But it truly is good enough to be have its very own recipe post. Sometimes I just make some for the heck of it, just to keep in the fridge (just reheat gently to make it pourable again). It’s fantastic slathered on a piece of very dark chocolate with a little sea salt sprinkled on top. Or drizzled over low carb coffee ice cream. Or simply licked from the spoon.
I really don’t think there is a better low carb caramel sauce out there. And there may not be a way to improve upon this recipe. But believe me, if there is, I will find it!
Scroll down to see all the great low carb recipes that use this low carb caramel sauce.
How to Make the Best Low Carb Caramel Sauce:
The Best Low Carb Caramel Sauce
This is the only low carb, sugar-free caramel sauce recipe you will ever need. It's ooey, it's gooey and it stays pourable! Best of all, it tastes just like the real thing.
Ingredients
- 1/4 cup butter
- 6 tbsp Swerve Sweetener
- 2 tbsp coconut sugar OR 1 tbsp blackstrap molasses (you can use additional Swerve here but your caramel sauce will harden a little more upon cooling).
- 1/2 cup heavy cream
- 1/4 tsp xanthan gum
- 1/4 tsp kosher or sea salt
- 2 tbsp water
- 1/2 tsp additional kosher salt or sea salt
For Salted Caramel Sauce
Directions
- In a medium saucepan over medium heat, combine butter, Swerve, and coconut sugar. Bring to a boil and cook 3 to 5 minutes (be careful not to burn it).
- Remove from heat and add cream. Mixture will bubble vigorously.
- Sprinkle with xanthan gum and whisk vigorously to combine. Add salt.
- Return mixture to heat and boil 1 more minute. Let cool to lukewarm and stir in water until well combined.
- For salted caramel, simply stir in additional salt at the end.
- The sauce can be stored in the fridge for a week or so (I've actually stored mine for several weeks). Just gently reheat in the microwave or in a saucepan to make it pourable again.
Recipe Notes
Serves 8. Each serving has 3.42 g of carbs using coconut sugar and 3.17 g using blackstrap molasses.
*You can use all Swerve for this. However, your end result will be lighter and will recrystallize more upon cooling.
Food energy: 113kcal Saturated fatty acids: 7.07g Total fat: 10.57g Calories from fat: 95 Cholesterol: 35mg Carbohydrate: 3.42g Total dietary fiber: -- Protein: 0.37g Erythritol: 11.25g
Looking for delicious low carb, high fat recipes that really satisfy? Check out my new cookbook, The Everyday Ketogenic Kitchen.
RELATED RECIPES
Salted Caramel Brownie Cupcakes
linda says
Coconut sugar or molasses! Neither are healthier than regular granulated sugar – although they sound “natural”. Fructose is more dangerous than glucose. Carolyn please keep working on this recipe – how about Yacon syrup? Tastes great and would make a good substitute I think.
Susan says
FWIW, black strap molasses is much lower in sugar than other forms of molasses. In fact, it really doesn’t taste sweet at all, and to my taste, much more like black licorice. I don’t have diabetes, and while I have given up sugar virtually entirely, I do occasionally use a bit of blackstrap in things like barbecue sauce – mostly for the subtle burnt-sugarish undertones.
It is extremely high in many essential minerals. It’s sort of a villain with some virtues.
Carolyn says
Linda, I know exactly the choices I have here and how “healthy” they are or are not. I have chosen these things because they WORK in this recipe. The small amount of sugars in this keep the caramel soft but don’t raise the carb count much at all. I feel strongly that this small amount per serving is not an issue. Yacon syrup also contains fructose so if you need to steer clear of that entirely, I am afraid it’s not a great sub after all.
Victor says
Do you think I could replace the coconut sugar for honey?
Carolyn says
That should probably work.
Victor says
Thank you so much =D
John Smith says
Woman, your gonna ruin me! Middle of the danged night, and I’m up making caramel….LOL
I seen someone’s post on Facebook making turtles, so I needed a keto friendly caramel recipe, and you never disappoint. Anyways, I did them using some chocolate turtle molds I picked up at a garage sale a few weeks back, and also using your chocolate chip recipe (with just 1 more Tbsp of erythritol, it makes a pretty decent dark yet sweet chocolate bar).
Anyways, I tried to cut down on the “sugar” in this recipe a little bit by only using 1 tsp of black-strap molasses. I compensated for the other 2 tsp (flavor wise) by using 2 Tbsp of “Just like sugar Brown” in lew of 2 Tbsp of erythritol (only used 1/4 cup of that), and then also using 1/4 tsp of toffee flavored liquid stevia to bring the hammer down on that molasses flavor. I also browned my butter a bit first, so when I added the tsp of molasses, it really got dark. It stayed pretty much like caramel even just above to room temp, but I guess I’ll see what it acts like tomorrow in chilled turtles.
I put about a tsp+ of caramel with each turtle, and they seemed to have turned out pretty good, at least the deformed one that I devoured seemed exquisitely caramely (is that a word?). I ran out of turtle molds, so I got out my mini snickers candy bar molds (same garage sale), and proceeded to do some more pecan caramel chocolate bars, and even tried a batch with peanuts instead. Of course, then I ran out of chocolate half way thru, so I had to break into my emergency reserves of pre-made chocolate chips I had sitting in the freezer. I guess I’ll need some sort of a “nougat” to get a true Snickers bar (please let me know if you come up with that ;-).
Again, thanks for all your efforts.
melanie says
Regular sugar has been depleted of its life forces, vitamins and minerals. It is processed. They make molasses out of all the minerals and vitamins from the regular sugar process.
Jen says
This is so rude! Telling her to “keep working on it.” Do you know how much time and effort go into recipe development?! If you have nothing positive to say, perhaps just leave your comments to yourself!
Personally, I can’t wait to try this! Thank you for all you do to create these recipes!
Carolyn says
Thanks! 🙂
Erica says
I agree with you, Jen! It’s one thing to respectfully disagree or ask for a sub (although that’s kind of bold, too). I’ve tried this both ways, and I much prefer the taste of the one with molasses to the one with coconut sugar. And I must confess, all I had in the cabinet was regular molasses. Guess I should buy some black strap.
Just another note: I made microwaved lemon curd using erythritol instead of sugar, and it turned very grainy in the fridge. Next time I’ll add a touch of the real stuff and see if that keeps it from doing this.
Anita says
Erica – I’ve had good luck using powdered erythritol in my curds. 🙂 Good luck!
Debbie Robin Archibald says
I feel exactly the same way. Every recipe I have tried is wonderful. If I see Carols name on it, I know it will be good. Thank you for all your hard work Carol!
Linda says
How much salt?
Carolyn says
It’s in the recipe.
Kapu says
How big is a serving? Looks “ono”. That’s delicious in Hawaiian.
Carolyn says
2 tbsp, it’s in the recipe
Kapu says
Thanks! Sorry, I must have missed it. Just so excited for caramel in my life again.
Edith says
O M G! You rock! You rock more than a rocking horse in a room full of small children! So, that being said… what do you usually use when making this… coconut sugar or blackstrap molasses? And thanks for all your work!
Carolyn says
I usually use coconut sugar. The molasses has a stronger flavour so I like the coconut sugar a little better.
Edith says
That would be my choice too. I used to say I wanted to have lunch with ‘Ellen’ but now I would say ‘Carolyn’ instead. I love you more! lol
Carolyn says
LOL! Thank you!
Maria says
I wouldn’t worry about that small amount of coconut sugar. It wont make that big an impact unless you sit and eat the whole recipe, and trust me, this is SO GOOD it is tempting to do just that! I have made this both with and without and you really need the coconut sugar to give it a ‘real’ feel. I have not tried it with molasses.
Carolyn this recipe inspired me to work on making some of my favorite candy low carb and sugar free and its has worked beautifully!
Carolyn says
So glad, Maria! And yes, I don’t recommend sitting and eating the whole batch. The 2 tbsp serving is quite generous and honestly, you don’t even need that much. It goes quite far in my other recipes where I use it…those are usually 12 to 16 recipes so it’s less than even in this recipe.
Reni says
I am going to cover some cashew nuts with this and bake – will let you know how it goes. And can’t wait to try this over my homemade vanilla ice cream yummmmmy.
Thanks you Carolyn for doing the work so we can have healthy alternatives.
Reni says
OK. I didn’t even make it past the BSM*+sugar+butter stage…I tasted it and thought OMG this is fabulous. I just poured that over my cashews and then stuck them in a 350 oven for 5 or so min, took them out and have been spooning them over and over on the parchment covered cookie sheet for about 10 min now. They are sooo hot I keep burning my fingers trying to taste them. Gonna sprinkle sea salt over them when they get cooler. I think I should have used almonds or pecans…or some other nut.
NOW. This carmel sauce with all of your ingredients is going to be made tomorrow for my homemade ice cream.
*The Black Strap Molasses gave it a really nice taste.
Reni says
I did boil the BSM+sugar+butter for the 3-5min.
Carrie says
Oooh…..this looks delicious! And I’m REALLY excited about the prospect of the maple pecan pie you mentioned – I’ve been thinking about how to stay low carb through Thanksgiving and pecan pie is the one dish I would really miss! Thanks!
Jana says
Hate recipes that require Swerve. 🙁
Carrie says
I wonder if you could use xylitol and get a good result – I use that sometimes and it seems to work really well in baking.
Carolyn says
Xylitol won’t caramelize as easily, which might not be an issue if you use the blackstrap molasses.
Molly says
Hiya !
I usually make my caramel with Xylitol – it doesn’t caramelise – you heat it up and boil it for a bit, then take it off the heat and add the butter and cream – they then go a sort of dark brown colour. The only problem with it is that it crystalizes horribly when it cools.
I buy bulk Erythritol by Now foods from iHerb – its just pure Erythritol – maybe that might work better for you than Swerve ?
Carolyn says
Hi Molly…no, plain erythritol won’t be better than Swerve, as I have tried it in the past. Swerve caramelizes better but both have a tendency to re-crystallize. It’s the coconut sugar/molasses and the xanthan gum that keep it from re-crystallizing so much. But you can use the Now erythritol in this recipe, it just might harden a bit more. Not sure.
joesy says
I used pure erythritol and two Tbsp coconut sugar and it turned out perfect no crystallized clumps just smooth caramel
Carolyn says
You can probably use other erythritol, you just may not get quite the same results. Why do you hate Swerve?
Joyce says
Carolyn,
You and your recipes are truly amazing! I made this recipe and it is to die for! I made a caramel custard recipe from another wonderful low carb cooking guru and then topped it off with this. I was in heaven!!
Your “cranberry jalapeno cornbread” recipe was so intriguing that I also made it today. It was delicious topped with a little butter and with my dinner tonight!
Thanks so much for making low carb an amazing way to live! In the meantime, I will be waiting for the next great recipe 😀
Carolyn says
Thanks, Joyce! Love hearing that it helps people.
Amanda says
Love this! Such a creative recipe!
Molly says
Just to add – THANKS for this – I have a recipe for caramel but it crystallizes 🙁 Am off to get some coconut sugar !
Agne says
Is there any replacement for Swerve? I really would rather not use it, besides its hard to get one here in Europe
Carolyn says
No, this recipe really depends on it. You can try plain erythritol but I don’t think it will work as well.
sandi says
I made this recipe yesterday with Now Foods erythritol (ground into powder) and about 1/4 tsp liquid stevia and I think it turned out as it is supposed to. I also had to use half and half instead of heavy cream ’cause that’s all I had. It thickened up very nicely and it is only slighly grainy when cold. I probably wouldn’t even notice the slight grainy texture at all if I used the caramel in a recipe. Next time I will only use 1 Tbsp of molasses though, as mine seems to be quite strong in flavor.
Carolyn says
Thanks for the feedback. I find the molasses to be a little strong too, but when I cut back on it, it does tend to get grainier. If you want it less strong, try coconut sugar – I have a bag and it lasts me forever because the caramel sauce is the only thing I use it in.
Rebekah Marquez says
Maybe 1 tbsp molasses +1 tbsp coconut sugar? I’ll be trying this with my lakanto monkfruit sweetener. It is similar to swerve & has erythritol as well, but I prefer it over swerve
sandi says
Sorry Carolyn, I forgot to say thanks for the awesome recipe. I am so looking forward to your Maple Pecan Pie recipe. To late for our Thanksgiving but I’ll be making it at Christmas time for sure.
Tarryn says
Delicious looking! I have made your other recipes with your caramel sauce as an ingredient, so I am looking forward to making a batch of this – my plan is to use it to concoct low carb cookie butter 🙂
Lisa says
Thank you! I’ve been looking for a lower carb version and it looks so good! I can’t wait to try it.
Mandy says
Thanks for sharing Carolyn – always churning out creative recipes. 🙂
Question: do you think full-fat coconut milk would work place of the heavy cream? Just curious. I know even the full-fat version is a bit “lighter” than heavy cream, but some recipes use them interchangeably. This recipe seems… er… a bit more sensitive… but I thought I’d ask. 😉
Thanks so much for sharing your creations!
Carolyn says
Yes, I think it would work pretty well. One reader says she does this all the time!
Peggy Cole says
Hi Carolyn! Thanks so much for the caramel recipe, just in time for the holidays. I have a question, could I use this to drizzle over cakes or cupcakes to replace using frosting? Thanks!
Carolyn says
You bet! It’s great on cakes and I’ve used it in frosting on my Salted Caramel Brownie Cupcakes.
Debra says
Thanks for the amazing recipe! It looks and sounds fabulous and I am going to make some. How is the moving going? Have you moved yet or still packing?
Carolyn says
We move officially on Nov 24th. Moving/pacing is still in progress!
Debra says
Oh my. I feel for ya! Going to be a busy prelude to Christmas!
Gransan says
I recently started using a sweetening product called “Just Like Sugar”. It is made of chicory root fiber. Would this work in your caramel sauce recipe? Thanks.
Carolyn says
I really don’t know without trying it myself. But I suspect not, since this recipe relies on erythritol. It’s worth a try, though!
Laura says
How can you make this vegan? Will a nondairy milk work?
Carolyn says
One reader has said that full fat coconut milk works. I haven’t tried it myself!
Meg says
I’ve had success with full fat coconut milk in other caramel recipes. I used cream for this one.
tiffany says
Is there a difference in molasses? I have a bottle of unsulphured molasses but it doesn’t say blackstrap.
Carolyn says
That’s fine. It has a slightly higher carb content (only 4 more g per tbsp, so it goes about .5 g per serving) and lower mineral content so it’s not quite as healthy.
Evan says
Oh goodness, I can’t wait to make this! I’ve been using the Walden Farms caramel sauce because it was (until now) my only option– and it’s not even very nice-tasting, let alone all the chemicals in it!!!
I’m just curious Carolyn, have you ever tried tagatose? I’m told it caramelizes exactly like table sugar so it’s good for caramels and things that require browning. It’s so expensive and hard to find though!
Best of luck and speed with your move, and thank you so much for taking time out of this busy and stressful period to keep us supplied with new recipes. You’re the best!
Carolyn says
I haven’t tried it but I have heard of it. I am leery of things ending in “ose” as that denotes a sugar and I am suspicious of claims about low glycemic index. They said the same thing about agave and it spiked me as much as table sugar. I’d have to try it on my own blood sugar before I’d use it in recipes for readers.
Abi says
LOVE THIS! I used Xylitol and Molasses as it’s all I had and it it turned out perfectly…could seriously not tell the difference in a normal caramel taste! I do grind my xylitol to a fine powder first before anything I cook with it, so maybe thats why it worked so well with the xylitol? Either way, thanks for the recipe! Even though the xylitol I used brought the carb count up, it is still a HUGE winner and healthier than a regular caramel. Cheers from Aus!
Carolyn says
So glad it worked out!
Ana says
If I double the recipe and then eat it ALL- is that considered a serving?!!!! Bwahahaha!!! AwEmAzInG!!!!
Ana says
What is considered a serving???
Kapu says
I think it’s 2 tablespoons.
Dinah Cox-Moore says
this is the best danged caramel sauce!!! You rocked it Carolyn!!
Carolyn says
Thanks, Dinah. Based on your feedback, I may change the recipe for 1 tbsp blackstrap molasses instead of 2. I think it’s just too much .
Nancy says
Hi, Carolyn. I made this sauce for your pecan pie recipe and although I burned it slightly, it still had a wonderful caramel taste. Do you have any tips to keep it from burning? I watched it very closely and stirred it often. I cooked it for 4 minutes. Do I need to stir it constantly and cut down on the time? Or is constant stirring the key? By the way, loved the pecan pie!!! I wasn’t a huge fan while it was still warm but after leaving it in the fridge overnight it was AMAZING! Thanks for all your low carb desserts that don’t leave us missing our high carb alternatives.
Carolyn says
It could be your pot or the heat of your stove. Is it electric? If so, turn it down a bit and do stir pretty constantly.
Betsy Stokes says
I found that the brand of butter mattered in the burning risk. Great Value did fine. Kerrygold burned when I blinked at it.
Carolyn says
Interesting!
Barbara Sacco says
Hi Carolyn,
Just a quick question – if I wanted to make caramel candies with this, what would I need to alter? I’m looking to make something close to the wrapped caramels we used to buy by the bag. Thanks so much for all you do!
Barb
Carolyn says
I am not certain you can make this into caramel candies…at least not the really chewy kind that stick to your teeth. Because it’s not sugar, and it just won’t quite work that way. But you could try boiling it down further until it’s a little more gummy. Then it will begin to harden more as it cools and you might have something you can work with.
Louanne says
Marvelous recipe, as always! Can I sub this caramel sauce in your chocolate pecan bars?
Carolyn says
Yes, I think you could!
Common Sense says
“this sauce will blow your caramel-loving mind.”
It sure the heck did! Just amazing!
I made it with the coconut sugar, which I had on hand from my early keto days but haven’t used since. Now I will! I do seem to have quicker cooking times, maybe because I’m at altitude, mine was about 2 minutes.
I used it for this:
http://www.averiecooks.com/2014/10/caramel-apple-cheesecake-crumble-bars.html
Lots of subs but it looks devine, it’s for tonight’s dessert.
Thanks for another great recipe Carolyn! Every recipe I make of yours comes out perfectly!
dee says
Just made this and I am in love….. thanks for such a yummy recipe. I have to stop my self from gulping it down.
Anne O says
Carolyn-awesome sauce! Burnt my first batch badly. Electric stove……so second batch I used LOW heat and LeCreuset pot; start to finish 11.5 minutes. Total success. Went from almost crying to a happy dance. Making your pecan pie as a trial run today for Thanksgiving. Looking great now! Thanks for great recipes- good luck during your transition to the west coast.
Carolyn says
Yikes! I am so worried because our rental house will only have electric and I am so used to gas!
Teresa says
Carolyn Carolyn Carolyn Carolyn
I “almost never” comment, but I could not not comment on this recipe
this is the best stuff that I have ever made in the world of sweet sauce/syrup
thank you thank you thank you thank you
5 stars
two thumbs up
Carolyn says
Thanks for the lovely feedback!
Rebecca says
THANK YOU. I’m an espresso junkie looking for syrups that don’t use Splenda. Two tablespoons of this in my breve make me not miss my much mourned white chocolate powder. I used Swerve and molasses and skipped the Xanthum gum since I don’t have any. It works beautifully in coffee. I’ll be making this in bulk!
Betsy Stokes says
Wha??? In coffee? Why didn’t I think of that. I’m trying it TODAY! 🙂
Kapu says
Will it work with regular molasses? Does it need to be the blackstrap? 🙂
Rebecca says
Kapu- I used regular molasses and think it turned out well.
Vicki K says
Bravo Carolyn..
This is the first low carb caramel I have made looks and taste like caramel.
Come summer, caramel sundaes will be on the menu…
I hope your move is going well!
Carolyn says
Thanks, Vicki!
Meg says
I commented on your magic cookie bar recipe, but this caramel is so good I had to thank you here too. I didn’t think low-carb caramel was possible, but I am sooooo happy it is. Thank you Carolyn!
In case anyone is looking for substitutions, I used xylitol instead of Swerve and it turned out great (for my other sweetener I used coconut sugar). I put my bars in the fridge last night and the caramel hasn’t crystallised at all.
Leigh Owens says
I must have done something wrong. I followed the directions exactly except I cooked it in the microwave instead of the stove. I was scared to “overcook/burn it” like the recipe warned so I just cooked about 2 minutes total. I guess just enough to melt the butter then i put the cream in. the end result is not thick or brown. It’s really runny and yellowish??
what did I do wrong?
Thanks
Carolyn says
Yes, well…caramel sauce like this requires the heat of a stove to caramelize. So what went wrong is that you cooked it in a microwave. Not really sure what else to say.
Leigh Owens says
Hi there, thank you for the response. Even though the caramel sauce did not turn out for me I made the salted caramel cream cheese frosting for cupcakes. OMG, they were SO good. so, thank you for that.
I tried again tonight (the caramel sauce) because I am making your pecan pie bars! I did it on the stove this time and and cooked it and cooked it (around 21 minutes). I was scared to cook any longer (swerve is expensive and I did not want to ruin it) but it never did get to the golden color of yours in the pictures. The pecan pie bars are cooling right now. I am excited to try.
I live in East TN. I wonder if we have different altitude issues than where you live? Would that make a difference in cooking times? I’m new to baking & eating low carb.
Carolyn says
I don’t think the altitude would be a problem. Did you use coconut sugar or molasses? That would give you the colour you want.
Leigh says
Well, one other thought. I bought swerve powdered instead of granular. Maybe that was it. I used coconut sugar instead of Molassas. When I made the bars I didn’t have vegetable glycerin so I used sf syrup. They came out more like cookie bar than what yours looked like. They tasted really good though and I guess that’s what matters. Thanks!
Carolyn says
Yes, taste wins in the end! I don’t think the powdered swerve would keep it from getting golden and caramelized but I could be wrong.
Leigh Owens says
Hi Carolyn,
Well I have kept at it (making the caramel sauce). What I found today was that the granular Swerve DOES make a difference. I used the granular and it cooked right up just like you said! I thought I would let you know just in case anyone else has that same problem( not browning up). I am making your salted caramel brownie cupcakes & toffee recipes. Thanks for taking all the hard work out for the rest of us by coming up with these delicious ideas.
Carolyn says
That is VERY good information! Thank you for keeping at it.
Kapu says
Okay! Finally made this, AND, OMGEE! Best sauce ever! One million times over. My dad who is visiting from home, Hawaii, is a lover of the other white crack. That being sugar. Well, gave him some Breyers Low Carb ice cream (hey it fills the void) drenched with sauce. He had two bowls and didn’t even now it was refined sugar free. This is a man who was born with a sugarcane stick in his mouth. I’m now needing to make another batch. First batch will be gone in 2.5 seconds. This is the next best thing to sliced bread.
Kapu says
“Know” not now. Oops.
Carolyn says
Wonderful! So glad he didn’t notice at all 🙂
Kapu says
I’m on my second batch of this caramel crack in two days. This will be the death of me.
Jamie Karutz says
I love you. Marry me? Oh dang, I went stalker creepy again 😉 I just made this and oh em gee. Yum. Love. My type 1 daughter and type 2 friends and family are going to have a very Merry Christmas, indeed.
Cat Latuszek says
Made this today with xylitol and coconut sugar since it was all I had in the cupboard and it turned out good. Tastes just like the caramel on caramel corn. Not sure if that’s how it’s supposed to taste, but it’s still good so that’s all that matters.
I did burn the first batch though, and I feel it prudent to mention to people that sticking your finger in the pot to taste-test it to see if it’s worth saving is like the worst idea. Ever. Your finger will hurt for a while. :p
Carolyn says
Yeah, it gets VERY hot!
unterderlaterne says
My kitchen smells divine as I just finished with your FABULOUS recipe for CARAMEL SAUCE. Carolyn- my hat off to you !
I did however burn my tongue- really stupid of me ! It is sooo hot and stays hot for quite a while. Never ever add the water to the just completed boil as I did. I lost 1/4 of the perfect concoction as it bubbled all over my stove.
Lesson learned*always follow directions to the letter!
Thank you Carolyn so much! Barbara
NGreene says
HI!!! I’m making the magic cookie bars and just finished my first ever batch of this caramel sauce. (which WILL NOT be my last!) I was so stinkin surprised! The first words out of my mouth when I tasted a bit – “Daggone. That’s good stuff.” I laughed at myself for being so surprised. 😉 Thank you for sharing your creativity in these delicious recipes!
Carolyn says
Thanks! Glad you like it. I can’t make it too often or I’d eat the whole batch! 🙂
Vicky says
FYI to all- I made this with half Swerve and half Splenda and it came out wonderfully. (I used the 2 tbs of coconut palm sugar). I made the recipe once before with all Swerve and I don’t like the cooling effect. Also Swerve is too darn expensive. Yes, I know Splenda is artificial. At this point in my eating adventures, that doesn’t really bother me. This batch is delish, the color is fantastic, the consistency is perfect!
Mary says
Hi! This looks delicious and I would love to use it to make the pecan pie. I am slowly building my low carb baking pantry and I don’t have xanthan gum, but I do have guar gum. Since it is such a small amount, do you know/think guar gum would work as a substitute in this recipe? Thank you so much for working on these recipes, they are very inspiring!
Aurora says
Really good one! Wondering if a dairy-free version using canned coconut milk would work?
Carolyn says
A few readers said that they had good luck with that.
Louise says
Have made plenty of your recipes and a die hard fan: always frustrated that we don’t get Swerve in the UK (or I could buy 485g for £61! on Amazon). We have a stevia/eritherol sweetener called Truvia. Do you think this makes a good sub?
Where can I find the composition of Swerve to try and compare? Is it pure erythritol? What is the consistency like? Truvia is quite grainy, like white sugar.
Carolyn says
Yes, I am sorry it’s so pricy elsewhere. Here’s the info on Swerve: http://www.swervesweetener.com/about-swerve/
Truvia is an okay substitute but it doesn’t come in powdered form, as confectioner’s Swerve does. You will get better results if you attempt to powder the Truvia yourself in a coffee grinder or some such thing.
kim langford says
How much is serving in teaspoons?
Carolyn says
1 tablespoon equals 3 teaspoons. So 6 teaspoons.
Cat Latuszek says
Felt like I should add…it makes for a good substitute for honey in salad dressing recipes…had some in the fridge and tried it out on a whim in an apple cider vinaigrette…worked really well.
LDee says
I bow to you O Goddess of low carb caramel sauce! My low carb life is so much sweeter since I found your site. Incidentally, I used 6 Tbs erythritol a dropper full of stevia & 1Tbs coconut sugar, 1/2Tbs blackstrap molasses. Came out perfectly!
naila says
Can splenda be used? and if so how much? I don’t have swerve…
Carolyn says
No, splenda will not caramelize like erythritol.
Dabz says
Actually, for the record, I DID make this yesterday with Splenda and Coconut Sugar, at the measurements listed, and it turned out great!
lynn says
OH….MY…GAWD!!! This caramel sauce is freakin AMAZING! it tastes just like a liquefied wearther’s caramel candy. I’m in love 🙂 I used organic stevia, and molasses. Thank yooouuuu!!!!
Dante says
Thank you for this awesome recipe. I’ve been looking for a way to use up coconut sugar, since I’m low carb now and generally can’t use it in recipes.
patti says
Incredibly delicious! It is very hard to find a sugarfree caramel sauce. Tried the coconut sugar for the first time – what else do you use it in? Great on brownie waffles recipe! Thanks!!
Carolyn says
I love it over ice cream, that’s my favourite.
Angelina says
Thank you so so much for creating this!!! I love good, grainy caramel and now I can make it in no time! Just a tip for those who do not want to use molasses or coconut sugar: add some stevia liquid to balance out the Swerve/erythritol coolness and add a teaspoon of maple extract to help make up for the flavor missing from the lack of molasses. It does come out off white colored but after you taste how amazing it is, you’re not going to care. I made a double batch and have to stop myself from sneaking spoonfuls when I’m near the fridge.
Victor says
Hey Angelina, even without the coconut sugar and molasses, was it okay? Did you refrigerate it? Does reheating it make it not grainy again? I’ve never used erythritol before and I was thinking of using Xylitol instead, but the side effects and the calories make me not want to use it. I wanna make this, but don’t wanna use the coconut sugar because it’s very expensive.
Victor says
Please reply to this comment instead of the other one because I forgot to click on the “notify follow up comments). I’d very much appreciate it =D
Angelina says
Yup, I refrigerated it and just heated it up on the stove top or microwave when I wanted to use it. So yummy…..
Yes, it tasted great without the molasses or coconut sugar…I think the maple extract helped a lot in substituting.
I’ve tried out almost all fake sugars and found that a combo of erythritol and pure liquid stevia works the best (the stevia balances out the cool after taste you typically find with erythritol) as far as taste, avoiding stomach upset and preventing raised blood sugar. I LOVE to bake so always keep granular erythritol (brand doesn’t matter), pure liquid stevia (from Trader Joes) and powdered Swerve on stock.
Cynthia T. says
I was wondering if you could substitute monk fruit for the stevia and sugar alcohols? I can’t consume any of those. I’m allergic to stevia (it’s a ragweed) and have terrible GI problems with sugar alcohols. Any ideas?
Carolyn says
No, there’s simply no way. Monkfruit will not caramelize. Sorry!
Sally says
This is delicious!! just as it is!!! I am wondering how I can use it?? Just dipped it on an Atkins bar and I am soon happy to have a treat!! Thanks for a simple recipe… !!
Julie says
Hi, thank you so much for this site and this wonderful recipe. Found it when I was looking for your Pecan pie recipe. What could you use in place of xanham gum? Chia, Flax, Arrowroot powder, Tapioca? Thank you.
Carolyn says
None of the above, I’m afraid. Xanthan inhibits recrystallization, which is why I used it. You can skip it, but do expect your caramel sauce to be more gritty and hard when it cools.
Sandy says
I this stuff. I have made it several times. I use salted butter and leave the salt out. It’s perfect!
Robin says
Wow! I just finally made this. I can’t get swerve, and I only had a little bit of erythritol, so I went half erythritol and half measurable Splenda. Also, I didn’t really have enough molasses and was all out of blackstrap. But even so, it tastes amazing and so far no crystallizing. I mixed some with lightly toasted pecan pieces and put it on top of a pumpkin cheesecake. Later I’ll add the whipped cream on top. This is for my husband’s birthday cake and I’m pretty excited. Why did I wait so long to make this?
Carolyn says
Glad it worked so well!
Erika says
So, would this work to make flan. I would usually melt sugar to make the caramel sauce, but I know sweeteners do not melt like sugar does.
I want to make salted caramel pot de creme, but not sure if this would work.
Carolyn says
Yes, this would probably work with flan.
Hkwdesign says
I’m having a high insulin issue, and the thought of not having pecan pie this Turkey Day was making me very sad, so thank you!
Wondering what to sub for the heavy cream – can’t do lactose…coconut milk (the thick creamy kind?)
Carolyn says
Yes people have had success with coconut milk in this recipe.
Allie says
Hey guys! Do you know if using coconut milk makes it have that coconut taste? Evn a little? I’m scared of that coconut taste infiltrating the caramel! Think cashew milk would work??
Carolyn says
I think coconut milk would have a bit of coconut flavour. I am doubtful that cashew milk is thick enough to produce a proper caramel sauce but you could certainly try!
Natasha says
Thank you for this recipe! I don’t have swerve so I used 4 tablespoons of trim healthy mama sweet blend and a half tablespoon of molasses. The first time I made it, I used a whole tablespoon of molasses and it was too strong for me so I used half. It’s delicious! I am using it to top my turtles cheesecake!
Carolyn says
So glad it worked!
Eileen says
Which taste better the coconut sugar or the molasess?
Carolyn says
I prefer the coconut sugar.
JeepersJulie says
Used this recipes to make a saled caramel apple sauce for my grain free gingerbread pancakes. Satisfying without being obnoxiously sweet!
I made a few modifications which worked out really well for me:
3/4 Xylosweet
1/4 Stevia in the Raw
a dropper full of vanilla creme stevia drops
Subbed full fat coconut milk instead of heavy cream
Blackstrap molasses added a depth of flavor that I really loved.
*On a side note; I find it offensive that an earlier reader demanded the creator of the recipe modify it to satisfy the reader’s opinions. If you won’t like how a recipe is written, make your own modifications! Simple as that!
Carolyn says
Hmmm, I don’t even remember that comment. But thanks!
Teresa says
Can I use arrowroot rather then zanthum gum? I’ve used it in other recipes but not desserts.
Thanks
Carolyn says
Not sure. Part of the reason for xanthan gum is that it inhibits recrystallization. Not sure that arrowroot would do that.
Paula says
Hi Carolyn 🙂 The caramel sauce came out perfect. Thank you for the recipe! I am also diabetic, and I think the Swerve is spiking my blood sugar. I know xylitol does for sure. I guess I get no break. But I’m sure if I tried this with plain old sugar, the spike would be worse. I’m afraid to try it. Anyway, I am going to try like maybe just one tablespoon. If I can’t handle it, I guess I should add insulin along with my Metformin, cause life’s just too short to live without caramel sauce!
Carolyn says
That’s unfortunate. I have no spike whatsoever from Swerve. Have you tested that out with just Swerve? It could be something else…like the coconut sugar.
Kim says
This recipe saved my caramel sauce! I was trying a recipe and their recipe was not working so I added some ingredients and instructions from yours and voila perfection! Thank you!
Carolyn says
Wonderful to hear!
Keto_nz says
Life just got better! *ahhhhh*
Kim Sorrentino says
Just to let others know – tried a double batch with 1 box (1C) Trader Joe’s Stabilized Whipping Cream, split the Coconut Sugar and Molasses (half of what is called for each) used 1/2C erythritol and 1tsp stevia glycerite – came out AMAZING!
Tastes like the caramel on Chicago’s Garrets Caramel Corn – YUM!
The only issue I had was blending the Xanthum Gum – got kind of clumpy. But after cooling down in fridge and upon reheating and stirring vigorously – it all came together beautifully! Great Job, Carolyn!
Minnie says
it says “Bring to a boil and cook 3 to 5 minutes (be careful not to burn it).” How do we know when it has cooked enough? With sugar, you can drop a bit into cold water to check for the stage it is at. Is there any way to judge when this is done? What will happen if it is under-cooked? I just tried – and ruined- a batch because it burned. . . it never stuck to the pan and the color didn’t seem to change as it cooked, then suddenly turned black with no intermediate stages!
Carolyn says
It should absolutely have intermediate stages of going more amber in colour. This is not the same as sugar, and it will smoke some as you boil it.
Ryan says
Would this hold its consistency in the freezer? trying to make salted caramel and hazelnut ice cream
Heather Ling says
Thanks for sharing! I made this with the molasses and it turned out well. The molasses made it a bit darker than expected (just for others to note) and my daughter thought it gave it a touch of pumpkin spice taste(?), haha. Will enjoy using this soon! ?
Kristine Cavanagh says
Do you prefer swerve in all of your recipes or do you sometimes use other sweeteners? And it’s fairly expensive, do you know where to get if for a reasonable price? Sounds delicious.
Carolyn says
I sometimes use other sweeteners but this recipe requires Swerve. It’s sometimes on sale, I would keep your eye on it for deals!
Suzan says
For dairy free, can I replace butter with coconut oil? I see I can use coconut cream in place of whip cream.
Thanks.
Terra says
I, too, used powdered xylitol with coconut sugar and it turned out AMAZINGLY! Thank you so much for this recipe.
Carolyn says
You’re welcome!
Karen says
This is fabulous, it’s always in my fridge now. Love it in my coffee! I am a convert.
Betty B says
Me too! I’ve been a mission to replace my caramel macchiato fix for some time. Sugar syrups, extracts, and oils just weren’t working. So nice to make this and get it right.
Jackie K. says
I made this with the syrup from http://sukrinusa.com/sukrin-fiber-syrup-gold/ & it turned out great! Seriously one of the best sauces out there. I actually used it to mix into a pie w/ coconut flour crust 🙂
Stephanie says
Which form of swerve do you use here? The granulated or the confectioners?
Carolyn says
Granular.
Jillian says
Really lovely recipe! I will make it today. I will be making the caramel with all coconut sugar. For some sad reason swerve gives me painful digestive issues. Hope it turns out. That being said It is doubtful that I will eat so many that the sugars will be harmful. I have been involved with health and healing since 1972 (!) and can happily say that I have never had health problems. In that time there have always been people lecturing on the dangers of any kind of sugars and whatever else they have decided is evil. I feel coconut sugar, maple syrup, and honey in small amounts have enhanced my health and well being. Those who are needing to lecture us all might need to start their own blogs… thanks for all of your real work involving health.
laurel Reynolds says
If you didn’t mind having some actual sugar in it could you sub out something like rapadura for the coconut sugar?
Carolyn says
I suppose that would work.
Becky says
Found it!, Can’t wait to try it, I love, love, love caramel! So excited!
Betty B says
Thank you Carolyn!
I’ve see-sawed back and forth on low carb/keto diets for years. It works great for me, but I typically cave in the latter part of the year with goodies from Halloween through Christmas. Being able to find low carb dessert options like this will make the transition so much easier and not feel quite so sacrificial. I look forward to following your newsletter and helpful posts.
Many, many thanks!
Carolyn says
Thanks, Betty!
Melanie says
Not sure what went wrong with my sauce but it separated from the butter. I used molasses. Should I try heating it up again?
I need it for your twix thumbprint cookies
Carolyn says
I am not at all sure why it separated. It’s never happened to me and I make this often. too much heat might be the culprit…keep it lower if you need too. Also, the xanthan gum should bring it all back together when you whisk it in.
Melanie says
I didn’t have xanthan gum so I used guar gum. Should I try cornstarch instead?
It looked really great before the second heating. When it said bring to a boil I really did crank the heat to get it to boil stirring constantly but maybe that’s what did it.
Michelle says
Could I make this into a caramel candy? How would I get it to that consistency?
Carolyn says
Sorry, I don’t really have any suggestions. It does harden a bit after cooling but you’ll never really get that chewy caramel consistency without sugar.
Michelle says
My sauce separated while cooking. Can anyone tell me what I did wrong?
Carolyn says
Did you use any ingredient different than the one I had listed? It should come back together when you whisk in the xanthan gum.
Stephanie Deal says
Made this sauce and it worked perfectly. :). I made it for the low-carb Twix cookies and will now be making it for other recipes (and ice cream) too. YUMMY — thanks again for a wonderful, easy-to-make recipe!!
Cheryl Wiley says
Just made this…it is excellent! Pouring over unsalted mixed nuts and freezing for a treat similar to peanut brittle. Thanks for all your hard work!
Carolyn says
Lovely.
Rsk says
I had to comment. This recipe rocks! I used full fat coconut milk instead of cream or half and half. I used 4tbsp erythritol and 2tbsp of brown sugar Splenda instead of Swerve. And a word to the wise, don’t use a plastic spoon, it melted in the Carmel, had to throw out that batch. Second batch, wooden spoon, perfection!
Kristy says
Made this to go on top of a apple pie bread pudding that I used your apple cider donut recipe and rehydrated dried apples in water with apple cider, swerve, and cinnamon. DIVINE! Seriously, this tastes like the real deal. I added 1tblsp of vegetable glycerin at the end to help with crystallization and I used the liquid from the apples after hydration in place of the water. THANK YOU!
Carolyn says
Wow, sounds fantastic!
Kristyn Miller says
Could you use Stevia (granulated) instead of Swerve ? We don’t have Swerve locally.
Carolyn says
No, stevia does not caramelize. You need some sort of erythritol based sweetener.
Maggie Slick says
I’d like to make a caramel that can go in the middle of a fat bomb to be similar to a rolo. Do you know how to do that or how to make this recipe a more chewy caramel? I am going to make this, but I’d love to make candies. (Oh, I mean fat bombs.) 😀
Carolyn says
Not sure how to make it chewy, sadly. But it does firm up in the fridge and then you could roll it into balls and dip in chocolate.
Maggie Slick says
That’s a great idea! I could also pour the first half of the fat bomb, let it partially harden, somehow put a dent in the middle and pour some caramel in, let that harden, then put the remainder of the fat bomb on top.
Jacq says
Carolyn,
I live in China so in the land of dumplings, noodles, and fried rice, living low carb hasn’t been easy. Now it’s apple season and I’ve been resisting the salted caramel I’ve been making for years. I just made your low carb caramel recipe, exactly as you wrote it with coconut sugar. OUTSTANDING. The swerve is undetectable. Thank you for everything you do for your followers!
Carolyn says
So glad you like it!
Zlatka says
Can I use this caramel sauce to make a caramel candy? Thanks!
Carolyn says
No, not really. It doesn’t harden and become chewy the way something made with sugar does.
Zlatka says
Thank you!
Sofie says
Hi Caroline,
if I make syrup with swerve, it crystalizes and becomes rock hard.
Do you think using xylitol would work? Maybe combining it with stevia (liquid)?
I’ve read somewhere that xylitol doesn’t harden like erythritol, …
Thank you for all your great recipes!!!
Carolyn says
Xylitol also doesn’t caramelize very well. So I think you need a combo of xylitol and erythritol
Sofie says
Will try that! Thanks!
Melissa says
Love your recipes! I am wondering if I can use this caramel recipe in place of the caramel recipe in the chocolate pecan pie bars.
Carolyn says
Yes, you should be able to.
Judy says
I just finished making this and it is absolutely amazing. Thank you for developing such a great recipe. Turned out perfect.
Tracey says
I’m so excited to try this! And the Twix Cookies! But I don’t have Xanthum Gum. Do you think I could use Glucomannan instead? I know they are often interchangeable.
Carolyn says
You probably could but I am not sure how much.
Chris says
Hi there! I think this recipe is great, but I am definitely doing something wrong and I’m not sure what it is. 🙁 The first two batches I made burned. I looked through the comments to see if anyone else had similar problems and I saw that for the electric stove I needed to lower the heat. I did that,but the problem is that it continued to burn without ever coming to a boil, despite vigorous stirring. I ended up just pulling it off the stove after about 15 minutes of hot-but not boiling – but still kind of wanting burn cooking and added the cream and the xanthan gum. I ended up putting it in my bullet to blend it because the gum didn’t want to blend completely. What I ended up with was still great – it has a very fluffy texture and it tastes wonderful, but it’s not the same product that we have here lol. Any advice? I use stainless steel cookware – could that be part of the problem? Thanks!
Carolyn says
It’s not the cookware, I have stainless steel too and have made this recipe plenty of times in it. I am really not sure what’s going on if you have your heat on low. It really shouldn’t be doing that. Is your heat on the lowest setting already?
Larissa says
This is fantastic!!!! I want you to know that we truly appreciate your hard work. Some people are just so ungrateful, and rude – if people want a caramel sauce with absolutely zero carbs, they’re better off buying some Torani caramel syrup and put up with all the chemicals and crap in it. 2 tbsp of coconut sugar is not much considering most people won’t be consuming the entire recipe all at once.
I am going to try and add some butterscotch extract to this and see what happens. Thank you again!!!
Carolyn says
Thanks for your support!
Meaghan says
Oh yeah, I made this yesterday because I have been missing caramel sauce something fierce. This is absolutely amazing!!! I used a packet of stweetleaf stevia because the other sweeteners cause stomach issues for me. I just poured a little over some homemade whipped cream and it was the best dessert I have had in months. I highly recommend! Thanks so much!
Carolyn says
So glad to hear it!
Carol Smith Walter says
Carolyn, Do you think this recipe would work for sugar free caramel chews? I was thinking if they are firm until heated I could cut them into squares and wrap them in wax paper.
Carolyn says
It’s not exactly chewy but it would be tasty.
Nicole says
This is so ridiculously good! I just made a batch to drizzle over your brownie cheesecake, also yummy. My husband and I both eat keto–I love sweets and baking and your recipes allow me both while still staying on track. Thank you so much!
I have two questions about the caramel recipe. First, will it work with powdered Swerve? I need to make a second batch to make one of your cookie recipes for book club and only have powdered. Second, if I swirl it into ice cream, will it harden too much?
Thanks again!
Carolyn says
I think it will work with powdered but not sure. Not sure about the ice cream either but it sure sounds good!
Shirley says
I’ve ordered some Swerve as it’s not available in my area but if I wanted to make this to go with the butter cake for a dinner tomorrow night which of the sweeteners I currently have would work best? I have Stevia in the Raw, Pure Via Stevia Granulated, Truvia Baking Blend and Now Better Stevia (liquid). I’m guessing the Truvia Baking Blend would work best but confirmation would be much appreciated. 🙂
Carolyn says
You can try the Truvia but honestly it’s much sweeter and I don’t know that it caramelized very well.
Ross says
Carolyn, I’m presenting Tuesday in my Biochemistry class for for my Natural Therapy Practitioner program (becoming a holistic nutritionist to promote healing through food, specifically ketogenic eating)
I’m making a bunch of keto truffles (using Lilys chocolate chips and coconut oil) and thought how decadent would salted caramel truffles be!?
Made this recipe using monk fruit/erythritol blend, molasses, and twice the xanthan gum. It’s cooling on the stove now, and HOLY **** this is amazing. I’m an ex-pastry chef and honestly this is as good as regular caramel.
Thank you for this amazing blog and so glad to see you still reply to comments.
Carolyn says
Thank you, I really love hearing that!
Carolyn says
Also, congrats on the holistic healing course!
Cindy S. says
Absolutely stunning sauce!
Dudley Shumate says
I came across this awesomeness because I found your Carmelita recipe awesomeness!! 🙂 Gonna make those to take to a dog show tomorrow. But quick question, I don’t have xantham gum?? Never used it? Not even sure where to buy? Can I omit/substitute?
Thank you, I am so eager to try the Carmelitas!!
D
Carolyn says
In this recipe, it helps to keep the caramel sauce from re-crystallizing. You can skip it but your sauce will get grainy. You can actually find it pretty easily in the gluten-free aisle of many grocery stores.
Dudley S Shumate says
What about chia or flax?
Carolyn says
that would not work here. Xanthan has properties that inhibit recrystallization. Chia and flax do not. And you’d end up with chunks of chia and flax in your caramel.
Dudley Shumate says
Actually I do have teensy ‘flecks’ but no chunks or pieces. I cooked ground flax with water and made a paste. Then used the paste after it cooled to room temp as per a google search on how/what to sub. And I whisked VERY VIGOUROUSLY until completely incorporated, like I don’t need an arm workout today! 😉
Carolyn says
🙂 Glad you like it.
Dudley Shumate says
O.M.G!!!!! Just made this caramel sauce for your carmelita recipe. It’s a miracle I am not now making just plain ‘Litas’ as I wanted to eat all of it!! And I don’t even like caramel that much. It is BEEEYOUTIFUL!!!! I did sub for the xantham gum, used flax. And used 5tbsp baking stevia (what I had) + 2 tbsp coconut sugar. It is superb. Reading notes, I opted to stir mine the whole entire time, start to finish. Perfect. THANK YOU!!!
Linda H. says
Hi Carolyn, thanks for such a delicious tasting caramel recipe. I read in the description that it is supposed to be “ooey” and “gooey”, but the texture on mine came out more like a soft pudding. The taste is absolutely delicious, but I’m not sure the texture like yours. The texture of yours looks like a liquid carmely, gooey texture. But mine is not like that. Like I said, it’s like pudding. I didn’t substitute anything. As I was cooking the butter and sugars, swerve, I was really excited because it looked and tasted like caramel, but then when I added the cream, it became soupy like milk, then added the xanthan gum and cooked for another minute or so and it thickened up a bit, but didn’t have that carmely texture. It started to be more like pudding or gravy. What did I do wrong? It’s still delicious, but I miss the carmely texture.
Carolyn says
It sounds as if you didn’t cook it long enough, although I can’t say for sure. When you add the cream, it should boil and bubble like crazy, not become soupy.
Linda H. says
I did notice that the cream didn’t boil up when I added it. I boiled the sugars for 5 minutes. I didn’t want to burn it. Is there a test or a way to tell if the mixture has been cooked enough before adding the cream? Again, thanks so much for sharing this wonderful recipe and taking time to answer questions. It’s really appreciated.
Carolyn says
There’s no real test but if the mixture is ready, it kind of boils thickly, if you know what I mean…like the bubbles come to the surface more slowly and lazily.
Heidi says
Is there a way to keep the Swerve from re-crystallizing after it cools so that the texture isn’t gritty? How about replacing it (or the coconut sugar) with xylitol?
Also, you can buy molasses extract on Amazon if you really don’t want the carbs from it. It tastes the same, but be aware that it’s extremely expensive.
Amy says
Hi Carolyn,
I was skeptical, oh so skeptical, but oh my goodness this caramel sauce is so delicious! I am insulin resistant and eat a low to moderated carb diet. I have to be very careful of my sugar intake and am about to enter into the world of sugar free ice cream. This sauce is delicate in flavor and truly does taste like the “caramel” of a buttery “caramel corn”. I made this and your hot fudge sauce and both are just divine! I am usually pretty sensitive to the “cooling sensation” of Swerve but in these recipes I don’t really detect it. I followed the recipes to the letter with the ingredients provided, no substitutions. For the caramel sauce I used the coconut sugar as it was the easiest to find at my local Walmart. Thank you for working so hard on recipes and maintaining your site. I think you are the most comprehensive out there and so far that I have found, the most delicious! Next I will be trying out your ice creams to go with these delicious sauces! Thank you!
Sharon says
Hi, do you know if THM gentle sweet will work in place of the Swerve? Also, can xantham gum be replaced with glucomannan in this recipe? I made your Kentucky Butter Cake a few weeks ago and it was delicious. This time, I want to make this caramel sauce to go with it but wondered about making those substitutions. Thank you!
Carolyn says
Since THM sweeteners are much sweeter than Swerve, they don’t caramelize as well and you don’t have as much volume. So you can try but I can’t guarantee the results.
Frances Heck says
O.M.G. Best caramel sauce ever. The coconut sugar really adds to the smell of caramel.
Betsy Stokes says
Because of this recipe, my teens, who were getting a little keto-bored, now think I’m magical. That is all.
Carolyn says
Yay! We like keto magic.
Elisabeth says
I love this! Is there a way to make this a recipe that can be hardened and cut into small candies?
Carolyn says
No, it doesn’t harden like that. Sorry.
Nicole says
Is there a replacement for the gum? Can I just omit it?
Thanks
Carolyn says
You can omit but your caramel will likely harden and crystallize more upon cooling.
Susan says
I made this for Thanksgiving Dinner (the first low-carb or keto dinner since becoming LCHF). It was a super hit! I didn’t have coconut sugar, so I used Truvia (plus, only two of the four at dinner are LCHF, maybe we’re making converts?)… I realize that changes the sugar content, next time I’ll use the right stuff.
Thank you for this recipe, my dear husband has already requested it as a repeat for Christmas Dinner!
Jen says
I made this for the Magic Cookie Bars, and made a double batch while I was at it, to put over ice cream. Yum! I had a thought, though, when I was just cooking the butter and sweetener, before I added anything else. When I set the spoon I was stirring it with down and the bits of mixture cooled, it seemed almost like penuche. I love penuche! I may try making a small batch and see how it turns out. It reminded me of when my mother-in-law used to make homemade caramels at Christmas and sometimes she cooked the mixture either too much or not enough (I’m thinking not enough now) and I liked it better than the caramels. Anyway, the sauce is amazing, whether on the magic cookie bars, on ice cream, or straight from a spoon 🙂 Thank you so much, Carolyn, for your recipes. My body is so much happier without all that sugar.
Robin says
OH MY GOSH!!! ABSOLUTELY DELICIOUS AND ONE WOULD NEVER, EVER KNOW THAT THIS IS LOW CARB!
YOU ARE AMAZING AND THANK YOU! THANK YOU!!!!
Carolyn says
Glad you like it!
Robin says
It was shy of a cup so I just used the whole amount for the Pecan Pie. SO eager for this pie tonight! It’s in the oven now. Cauliflower Crust pizza for dinner and pie for later…I’m in heaven!
Lisa says
This is a winner-so good drizzled with lc caramel sauce (your recipe too). The only substitution I made is Bob’s Red Mill Fine Macaroon Coconut for the coconut flour-I don’t like the taste or texture of coconut flour but do like other forms of coconut.
https://www.bobsredmill.com/fine-macaroon-coconut.html
Lisa says
Sorry I meant I drizzled this over your LC Skillet Chocolate Chocolate Chip Cookie
Erin @ Dinners, Dishes, and Desserts says
Yes – I want to put this on everything!
Taylor @ Food Faith Fitness says
I can’t wait to put this on everything!
Jennifer Blake says
Perfect sauce for so many applications from cookies to ice cream to anything your heart can imagine!
Gerry Speirs says
I could drink this 🙂
Kristeena says
Sorry if this question has already been asked, but there are so many comments it’s hard to read through them all. Do you use granulated Swerve or confectioners? I find a lot of recipes don’t specify but one usually works much better than the other. Thanks!!!
Carolyn says
Granular.
Amanda says
I just finished making this! It’s delish!! I didn’t have Swerve, however the Pyure seemed to incorporate just fine. Everything melted well together, and it doesn’t even seem like it will crystallize at all. I’m making your caramel cupcakes in the morning. So excited to see how they turn out! Thanks for taking the time to perfect this caramel sauce!
Lucia Butler says
HI Carolyn,
Can you tell me, I think I missed it, the best way to store this? I love caramel lattes with almond milk and am so thankful I found this recipe. I will be taking this to work with me as I’ll be making my lattes and not buying them anymore. I thought I would have to give them up completely. I put the caramel sauce into a Ball jar – is it ok to leave on the shelf or best in the fridge.
Lucia Butler says
Hi Carolyn
Lucia again – disregard my previous comment/question! I reread the recipe and found my answer. Thank you!
patricia says
Carolyn, can this be used to make caramel popcorn?
Carolyn says
I don’t eat popcorn but I can’t see why not.
Anita says
FYI – use ONLY the amount of molasses called for! I was so excited to use molasses, that I put just a titch extra in like I do for my molasses cookies. BAD IDEA. 😉
Carolyn says
Uh oh…too strong???
Sonia Mehrotra says
Hi….this had me drooling. Looks yum…but before I can try it I need a clarification. I can’t get xantham gum here..can I use arrowroot powder instead? If yes, how much would you recommend? Thanks for all the effort you put in on our behalf.
Carolyn says
Arrowroot would not be a good substitute in this case. You can skip the xanthan if you need to but it may not have a “syrup-y” consistency.
Sonia Mehrotra says
Hi…new as I am to Low carb diet I needed a small clarification. In my efforts to locate a seller for coconut sugar I did some research on this product. According to the info I gathered coconut sugar as exactly the same as regular white sugar apart from the hint of caramel flavour and it’s effects on the body are similar to regular sugar. Which brings me to the question would regular dark brown sugar do in the absence of coconut sugar for making this caramel sauce? Also may I know your reason for choosing coconut sugar over brown sugar?Thanks.