All Day I Dream About Food

All the best low carb keto recipes for a healthy lifestyle

Nutter Butter Ice Cream Sandwiches

This post may contain Amazon or other affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

Creamy sugar-free no-churn peanut butter ice cream sandwiched between two tender  low carb peanut butter cookies. This delicious low carb, grain-free dessert recipe requires no ice cream maker. What are you waiting for?

Close up shot of keto peanut butter Ice cream sandwiches

What do you consider the first day of summer? Do you go by the official solstice or is there another date that marks the occasion in your mind? I have heard some say that Memorial Day is the start of summer but I don’t get that. Perhaps it’s because I live in the northwest, where chilly, rainy temperatures can hold on well into June. They certainly did this year and it’s only just now beginning to feel a bit summery.

But for me, summer doesn’t really start until school ends. That’s how I saw it as a kid, as a university student, as an academic advisor and now how I see it as a parent. We aren’t free to enjoy summer weather until school is out so it’s best not to even consider it summer until that first day of freedom. For my kids, that’s not until next Wednesday, thanks to all of the snow days we had this past winter. So June 25th is the first day of summer this year, I don’t care what anyone else says.

But given that the “official” first day of summer is three days away, I felt duty-bound to offer up a truly summery treat. You can’t have summer without a good ice cream sammie recipe, right? I mean, hand-held ice cream treats are practically required when the mercury rises and the humidity strikes.

Remember being a kid and hanging out with your friends, riding your bikes down to the local convenience store to pick out popsicles and ice cream sandwiches? And then eating those treats, starting out slowly and lazily, then having to gobble them down faster and faster to avoid losing too much of the sweet goodness to the summer heat.

Gluten-Free Peanut Butter Ice Cream Sandwiches

Delicious low carb ice cream sandwiches

Of course, it’s not like we really have that option on a low carb diet. There is actually some pretty great low carb ice cream on the market now. But it’s not always easy to find, it’s expensive, and at this juncture, I don’t know of anyone making keto ice cream sandwiches.

Plus homemade often means that they taste better and I can play around with flavor ideas to my liking. Sure, it’s a little more effort, but I think it’s worth it.

And these low carb peanut butter ice cream sandwiches are especially worth it, because the ice cream filling doesn’t require any churning! Yep, you read that right. You do NOT need an ice cream maker to make these awesome low carb treats. And awesome they are, my friends, I do declare.

Low Carb Grain-Free Nutter Butter Ice Cream Sandwiches

Making no churn peanut butter ice cream

I originally intended for them to be made with churned ice cream, as I was going to use my low carb peanut butter ice cream recipe for the filling. Then I switched gears  at the last minute and decided I would follow the recipe for my low carb Peanut Butter Popsicles instead.

But the filling was so thick, I realized that I would have to thin it out a lot to be able to churn it in an ice cream maker. So I decided to skip the churning process altogether and slap it between the cookies as it was. And hope for the best upon freezing.

Thankfully, it worked perfectly. The thickness and richness of the “ice cream” filling means it doesn’t freeze overly hard. And it also doesn’t melt and drip everywhere as it warms up. It stays nice and creamy, right in the middle of your ice cream sandwich instead of dripping all onto the plate or the floor. I have to say, it might be one of my better last minute ideas…

Low Carb Nutter Butter Ice Cream Sandwiches

Want more delicious low carb frozen treats?

Neapolitan Ice Cream Cake

Butter Pecan Ice Cream Pie

Peanut Butter Brownie Ice Cream Cake

Snickerdoodle Ice Cream Sandwiches

Chocolate Chip Ice Cream Sandwiches

Easy Coffee Ice Cream Cake

 

5 from 8 votes
Print
Nutter Butter Ice Cream Sandwiches
Prep Time
30 mins
Cook Time
15 mins
Chill Time
2 hrs
Total Time
45 mins
 
Creamy no-churn peanut butter ice cream sandwiched between two tender peanut butter cookies. This delicious low carb, grain-free dessert recipe requires no ice cream maker. What are you waiting for?
Course: Dessert
Cuisine: American
Keyword: ice cream sandwiches, no churn ice cream
Servings: 16 Sandwich Cookies
Calories: 341 kcal
Ingredients
Cookies:
Peanut Butter Ice Cream Filling:
Instructions
Cookies:
  1. Preheat oven to 325F and line two baking sheets with parchment paper.

  2. In a medium bowl, whisk together almond flour, coconut flour, baking powder, and salt.

  3. In a large bowl, beat together peanut butter and coconut oil until well combined. Beat in sweetener, then beat in egg and vanilla extract.
  4. Beat in almond flour mixture until dough comes together.

  5. Form dough into 1-inch balls and place about 3 inches apart on prepared baking sheets (you should get 32 cookies).

  6. Use a flat-bottomed glass covered in parchment or plastic wrap to press cookies into flat discs about 1/4 inch thick. Score tops with a fork to create a criss-cross pattern.
  7. Bake cookies 13 to 15 minutes, or until just lightly browned and set. Remove and let cool completely.
Filling:

  1. In a large bowl, beat cream cheese and peanut butter until smooth. Beat in sweetener and vanilla extract.

  2. Add cream and beat until smooth.
  3. To assemble, take one peanut butter cookie and spread the bottom with about 2 & 1/2 tablespoons of peanut butter filling. Top with another cookie, bottom-side in.
  4. Repeat with remaining cookies and filling. Freeze cookies 2 hours before serving. If frozen longer, allow to soften at room temperature for 10 minutes before serving.
Nutrition Facts
Nutter Butter Ice Cream Sandwiches
Amount Per Serving (1 g)
Calories 341 Calories from Fat 275
% Daily Value*
Fat 30.5g47%
Carbohydrates 8.8g3%
Fiber 2.8g11%
Protein 8.4g17%
* Percent Daily Values are based on a 2000 calorie diet.

Nutritional Disclaimer

Please note that I am not a medical or nutritional professional. I am simply recounting and sharing my own experiences on this blog. Nothing I express here should be taken as medical advice and you should consult with your doctor before starting any diet or exercise program. I provide nutritional information for my recipes simply as a courtesy to my readers. It is calculated using MacGourmet software and I remove erythritol from the final carb count and net carb count, as it does not affect my own blood glucose levels. I do my best to be as accurate as possible but you should independently calculate nutritional information on your own before relying on them. I expressly disclaim any and all liability of any kind with respect to any act or omission wholly or in part in reliance on anything contained in this website.

Reader Interactions

We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon.com and affiliated sites.

Comments

  1. Summer definitely requires ice cream, regardless of when it starts. These look amazing! I’ve been loving the no-churn recipes this summer so I’ll have to give yours a try:-) Especially since they are peanut butter!

    Reply

  4. Carolyn, you are in my favorites and I check in daily….BUT this morning I saw these in Yahoo news!!
    I love that LC recipes are showing up in the news and what could be better than recipes?

    Reply

  7. My kids got out of school a couple of weeks ago, so we are well into the swing of summer. I must admit that I am loving the lazy mornings.

    You have once again proven that you are the queen of low-carb. These are brilliant, Carolyn!

    Reply

  9. I wish I could eat as much neat snacks as you without gaining weight. Maybe if I was as active as you I could. Love the LOOKS of all the things you offer and make some once in a blue moon. Whenever that is.

    Reply

  10. Hey! These look amazing! I have a ton of peanut flour could I substitute that for the peanut butter and almond flour? I’m trying to figure out measurements 🙂

    Reply

    • You can sub it for the almond flour, not so sure about the PB because you really need the moisture content. For the almond flour, you want less peanut flour because it’s much denser. Maybe 1 cup?

      Reply

  12. I will give these a try since I just bought a 4 lb bag of coconut flour at Costco. Is the peanut butter natural or regular? I don’t bake low-carb exclusively so when I see “creamy peanut butter” I’m thinking it’s regular.

    Reply

      • I made the cookies last night using natural peanut butter and they came out great. But now I’m out of peanut butter so it’s off to the Job Lot so I can make the filling. (Keeping my fingers crossed that they have my favorite, Brad’s Organic.)

        Reply

  16. No one from all the LC bloggers have impressed me as much as you ! I wish I had the time to try all your recipes! I am working on it ! Truly amazing food! Thank you Carolyn

    Reply

  17. Hi Carolyn,

    I noticed the Chocolate Covered Peanut Butter popsicles call for 1 cup of peanut butter, but you’ve only listed 3/4 cup in these sandwiches.

    Does it matter?
    Love your ideas!

    Reply

    • No, it doesn’t matter. I am always playing around with my recipes and I was trying to get the filling for the sandwiches a little less thick, and more ice cream-like.

      Reply

  18. Made these the day I saw the recipe – they did not disappoint! I had some fun pressing out the cookies (read: they gave me trouble), but they were just delicious! I can’t wait to make another batch!

    Reply

  19. Wonderful recipe!!! I used all almond flour and natural pb. I got 28 cookies, but mine were a little thicker than the pictures. If I thin them out next time I can get a couple more. I think this one is going to beat out the gingerbread cake as my all time favorite!

    Reply

  21. Can I use something other than coconut flour for this recipe, like use almond or peanut flour instead?

    Reply

    • I haven’t tested it with almond flour or peanut flour. Peanut should work but I think more almond flour would make the cookies too crumbly.

      Reply

  23. Okay, huge fan of this recipe! Any more no-churn ice cream-type of recipes? Also, Carolyn do you have any simple meals that use heavy cream? Plz point me in the right direction — AND THANK YOU!!

    Reply

  24. I made this delicious recipe. they taste just like nutter butter cookies. the only mistake I made is making them too big. next time I will make them small, will be easier to handle when assembling. and a lighter snack, as they taste very rich. love them! a keeper.

    Reply

  25. For some reason my cookies were crumbly. I used the exact ingredients listed. Would you know what I may have done incorrectly? Thanks!

    Taste wonderful though 😉

    Reply

    • Without being there, I cannot say for sure. Did you use almond meal instead of almond flour? Did they bake too long?

      Reply

  26. Just curious what your batter looks like before baked? Mine is very crumbly wondering if I packed my almond flour too tightly or something but not sure what the batter should look like.This is the second time trying almond flour cookies that the batter was super crumbly.

    Reply

    • I don’t pack my almond flour at all. Unless instructions say to do so, I wouldn’t. Also, are you using really finely ground almond flour like Honeyville? That would make a difference.

      Reply

  27. I was wondering about changing the sweetener for Splenda. Would the measurements be the same and how would the filling work? My wife has Gestational Diabetes and is about 7 months pregnant and Splenda is the approved sweetener for her. I would love to make these for her so any help would be appreciated.

    Reply

    • You can certainly try although I am not sure it will give the cookies the right consistency. I suspect they will be hard and crumbly. Swerve measure like sugar so you will need to figure out how much your Splenda measures in comparison to sugar.

      Reply

  28. Hi could I use almond butter instead of peanut butter? Sorry but my husband just can’t have peanuts and would love to try this for him. Many thanks

    Reply

  29. Yum! I’ll have to make some of the filling! I make low carb pb cookies using peanut flour. They’re like a peanut butter shortbread. I think putting some of the filling in would definitely kick them up a notch. 😀 (came by way of Facebook)

    Reply

  31. Hi, thanks for this wonderful recipe! The only issue I ran into is that my cookies turned out really crumbly and would fall apart upon picking them up. There was a small batch that seemed a bit more in tack and not as dark when I pulled them out however, they baked in the oven at the same time as the crumbly ones. Could I have overvalued the batch? I baked them for only 13 minutes. Just not sure if I did something wrong. Otherwise, they taste incredible!

    Reply

  32. I made these (the cookie part) yesterday and followed the recipe, exactly, sort of (I used almond butter, instead). The ‘dough’ turned into little chick pea sized balls and was crumbly. After mashing little balls together, I gently smooshed each little 1″ size ball onto the parchment paper and baked away. **FYI- YOU MUST LET THEM COOL DOWN BEFORE HANDLING!** or else they will literally fall apart.

    One they cooled, I ate a few and they were delicious. I’m still trying to get used to the coconut oil texture while eating them (BTW- I used ‘LouAna’ unscented/unflavored coconut oil, because sometimes its just too much flavor and overpowers the other flavors you want).

    Anyway, I’m a little confused about carb/fat/caloric breakdown just per 1 cookie. Is there anyway you can provide that info. I just want to to make sure that eating more than 3 or 4 won’t be too regrettable.
    Thanks!
    Brad in Las Vegas, NV

    Reply

  33. 5 stars
    Thank you so much!!! I made these yesterday and they are yummy! I followed your recipe exactly and the turned out perfect. I did try to lift a cookie before it had completely cooled and it fell apart so make sure to let cool before you assemble.

    Reply

  34. 5 stars
    Thanks for a great recipe—the ice cream filling is especially delicious! I was thinking that’s if you omitted the heavy cream, you could make regular non-ice cream butter butters. Before I added the cream, I noticed that the mixture looked a lot like the regular butter butter filling. Just thought I’d pass the idea along for anyone who might not have the time (or patience) to wait until they are frozen! I am really enjoying your site and am so grateful for you sharing so many amazing recipes. It makes going low-carb not only bearable but exciting!

    Reply

  35. 5 stars
    My favorite of all desserts! In my 2.5 years of Keto, I’ve tried a whole bunch!
    I was lazy and split the dough into 2-11×7 pans, baked them and let them cool, spread the filling and froze them. Perfect size pans for the listed portions!

    Reply

Trackbacks

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *