My whole family has a serious addiction to peanut butter. We can easily go through the 2-pack of large jars from our local wholesale club in under a month. It’s a little horrifying, actually, to think you just bought a whole wackload of peanut butter and then to discover that you are down to the last few scrapings in the jar. The problem is, we love it in all sorts of ways: on toast, on granola bars, in baked goods, and straight out of the jar with a spoon. It’s a quick energy snack when you need it, and it’s filling and satisfying. Oh, and it tastes good too. Really good. Especially with chocolate.
I enjoyed my first two experiments with peanut flour and started thinking of what else to make with it. My first instinct was peanut flour blondies or cookies, but I wasn’t quite sold on that idea. I let the idea keep rolling around in my mind, and somehow it transformed itself into a peanut flour coffee cake. And then, like a science experiment gone awry, it kept mutating away in my brain and finally became peanut butter muffins. I had some homemade chocolate chips in the freezer and I knew it would be a perfect match.
I really liked the texture of the muffins made with cream cheese from Jennifer Eloff’s blog, even though mine didn’t rise properly in the middle. So I knew I wanted to adapt the recipe for peanut flour and peanut butter. I gave a lot of thought to the right combination of wet and dry ingredients and oven temperature so that they would actually be muffin-shaped this time. Additionally, peanut flour is a lot denser than other nut flours, so I knew I couldn’t go all peanut flour or I might end up with muffins that were as dense as hockey pucks.
The Results: Would it be vain of me to say that I think I nailed it on the first try? Maybe, but I am going to say it anyway. I really love these. The texture is just right and the peanut buttery taste is spot on. And they didn’t sink in the middle! Honestly, the only thing I would change would be my chocolate chips, they were much meltier this time, and melted too much down the sides of the muffins. But that could be fixed with commercial chocolate chips or chopped Lindt bars. Or even no chocolate chips at all. I think the peanut butter flavour here was wonderful and would be great plain or with a smear of sugar-free jam.
These aren’t the lowest of the low carb treats I’ve ever made. Both the peanut flour and the peanut butter add some extra carbs, as do the chocolate chips. But there is also a lot of protein and fiber in these, and they are really satisfying and filling.
Peanut Butter Chocolate Chip Muffins
1 cup almond flour
1/2 cup peanut flour
1/4 cup vanilla whey protein powder
1/4 cup granulated erythritol
2 tsp baking powder
1/2 tsp baking soda
1/4 tsp salt
4 oz cream cheese, softened
1/2 cup peanut butter
2 tbsp almond milk
2 large eggs
16 drops stevia extract
1/2 cup sugar-free chocolate chips (or one 3.5oz 85% cacao Lindt bar, chopped)
Preheat oven to 300F and line a 12-cup muffin tin with paper or silicone liners.
In a medium bowl, whisk together nut flours, whey powder, erythritol, baking powder, baking soda and salt.
In a large bowl, beat cream cheese until smooth. Add peanut butter and almond milk and beat until combined. Add eggs and stevia extract and beat until combined, but do not overbeat.
Add dry ingredients in two batches, beating until just combined. Stir in chocolate chips.
Divide batter among prepared muffin cups. Bake for 30 minutes or until tops are set and golden brown.
Let cool in pan.
Serves 12. Carb count will vary depending on what chocolate you use, but with my homemade chocolat chips, each muffin has a total of 11.2g of carbs, but only 7.25g if you subtract erythritol.
Dana says
Can i use jif peanut powder for the peanut flour?
Carolyn says
I really don’t know, I’ve never tried it. But it’s worth a shot.
Becky says
My local Trader Joe’s doesn’t stock peanut flour. Do you think I could use cashew flour in its place?
Carolyn says
Sure, you can try that. It’s not as powdery as peanut flour but it should be okay. For the record, Trader Joe’s no longer carries peanut flour at all but you can purchase it on Amazon or Netrition.
Becky says
Good to know! Thanks!
homemadechocolatier says
there are few things that go together better than peanut butter and chocolate. these must be amazing!
Lizzy M. says
Where did you get the peanut flour? I haven't seen it in any stores. These look great!
Magic of Spice says
I still have so much peanut flour left, should start thinking up using it up 🙂 I love peanut butter too, and they look delicious 🙂
briarrose says
So yummy….we have such a peanut butter addiction as well. My hubby is always commenting that we "just" bought multiple jars and yet we need more. 😉
A little bit of everything says
my favorite way to eat PT is straight from the jar :)))
yeee for nailing this on the first attempt. they really look good.
Have a wonderful Sunday Carolyn
Kate @ Diethood.com says
These sound wonderful … would have been a delicious Sunday breakfast!
I'm also a PB addict…I put it in almost everything that I bake. Or I just go in there with a spoon… one of the two for sure. 🙂
Amy Bakes Everything says
Girl – you should never feel vain for nailing recipes! You amaze me your recipes – I know there's NO way I could get this on the first try, unless it was with AP flour and gran sugar! Great job!
Beth says
My family loves peanut butter too. Congratulations on nailing this recipe the first time!
baking.serendipity says
I am always game for another peanut butter and chocolate recipe 🙂 My husband and I are always stocking up on pb from Costco!
Foodiva says
These muffins look so perfect, it's hard to believe that they're way healthier than my normal version! Ever since I've started baking regularly, I think I've put on about 15lbs so I may have to go your low carb way soon!