And then I received some lovely samples from Oh! Nuts. You may remember the Cashew Ginger Granola Bars I made with their gorgeous cashews. Well, they also sent me a bag of their blanched almond flour and when I finished off the last of my Trader Joe’s almond meal, I opened it up. I instantly noticed a difference. It was much, much finer and since it was ground without the skins, it was paler in colour. And when I baked with it, I was more than a little impressed. It baked differently and the final product had a much finer, more flour-like texture. Since it doesn’t have gluten, I still had to compensate for that and add more binders and leaveners, but ultimately, it made a huge difference to the quality of my baked goods.
Now that I finally see the difference, I decided to tackle chocolate chip cookies again. The thing about baking without sugar is that it is difficult to mimic some of sugar’s qualities. Replicating the sweetness is the easy part. In that holy trinity of baking, flour, sugar and butter, there is something magical that happens that allows cookies to spread and become crispy and chewy at the same time. I just haven’t found a way to to make anything low carb and gluten free that even compares. Until now.
These were originally conceived to be breakfast cookies, and I thought that the dried cranberries and walnuts would make them more hearty. But I tasted the batter partway through and it was wonderful but rich, so I thought I should make them smaller and more dessert-sized. This is not to say that you couldn’t eat them for breakfast, because I will confess that I did. It’s just that they seemed more like dessert to me. I also used some grain-sweetened chocolate chips I found at the grocery store as I didn’t have the time or the patience to make my own low carb chocolate chips and these had about half the carbs of regular semisweet chips. And at the last minute, I decided to make them with coconut oil in place of the butter.
The Results: These cookies are phenomonal (or were phenomenal, because they didn’t last long). I would be lying if I said they were just like conventional flour-and-sugar chocolate chip cookies. They don’t have the same texture at all, and they don’t spread and get all crispy/chewy. But they are rockin’ their own special thang and it is a very delicious thang indeed. Because of the coconut oil, they almost melt away in your mouth as you bite into them. And the cranberries give a sharp little tartness that offsets the richness of the almond flour, walnuts and chocolate.
If I had more than two thumbs, I would give these more than two thumbs up. They aren’t just great low carb cookies – they are great cookies all around! I will be making these again for certain. Now, the tough part is that unsweetened dried cranberries are hard to come by. You can make your own, as I did before Christmas, with the recipe HERE. And I had some left over, which is what I used in these cookies. But in place of that, consider using fresh cranberries chopped in small pieces. The juice may run a little but I think it would work just as well.
Cranberry Walnut Chocolate Chip Cookies
2 ¼ cups almond flour
¼ cup granulated erythritol
½ teaspoon baking soda
½ teaspoon salt
½ teaspoon xanthan gum
1 large egg, lightly beaten
⅓ cup coconut oil, melted
½ teaspoon vanilla extract
16 drops stevia extract
¼ cup unsweetened dried cranberries (or fresh, finely chopped)
¼ cup chopped walnuts
¼ cup low carb chocolate chips (or chopped high % cacao chocolate)
Preheat oven to 350F and line a baking sheet with parchment paper.
In a large bowl, whisk together almond flour, erythritol, baking soda, salt and xanthan gum. Stir in egg, oil, vanilla and stevia until thoroughly combined. Stir in cranberries, walnuts and chocolate chips.
Form by hand into 1-inch balls, and place on baking sheet. Flatten with palm. Bake 7 to 10 minutes or until just starting to brown on top.
Let cool on pan for 5 minutes, then transfer to a wire rack to cool completely.
Makes 18 cookies. Each cookie has 8.2 g of carbs total, but only 5.2 g if you subtract erythritol.
Erica B says
Hi, Carolyn. Judging by the comments, this recipe has certainly stood the test of time thus far. I want to give it a go, but since you mentioned a possible update on it…is that something on your schedule for this holiday season? Just curious. ????
Carolyn says
I haven’t gotten to this one yet, sorry!
Erica B says
No need to apologize; I’m sure the cookies will be quite good as is. Thank you!
Robin says
FANTASTIC! I use a mix of erithritol, xylitol and stevia. They came out perfectly! Made 20. Thanks so much!
Carolyn says
This is an old recipe and I want to update it because they are tasty. Glad you liked them!
Jeannine says
Just made these and they are fabulous!! My batter was not dry at all, in fact a bit oily and the cookies baked up just fine. Thanks Carolyn for another wonderful recipe.
Jeannine
Patti says
Hi, Carolyn
I was wondering as I’m alergic to nuts do you think these could be made with sunflower seed flour or pumpkin seed flour.? All help appreciated. I also don’t have any liquid stevia. I have powered stevia, swerve, and cocoanut sugar, also Surkin gold
These look amazing I can’t wait to make them. I just bought cranberries. You have great recipes. I know how much work goes into trial and error of baking GL free.
Thanks so much
Carolyn says
Yes, you can use sunflower seed flour but use a tbsp of lemon juice to avoid a greenish tinge. You can use whatever sweeteners you like best. Thanks!
Suzan says
I made this last night. I left out the walnuts because I didn’t have any. For the chocolate chips I use 70% cacao chocolate. I doubled the recipe because we are having company. I ended up with 55 cookies at 2.38 carbs each. I’ll be making these again. Yum.
I was wondering if these would work as a cookie bar recipe instead of individual cookies. Also could they be made with butter instead of coconut oil?
I was so thrilled to find your recipe because a friend had made similar cookies that weren’t low carb. They were great and I wanted to be able to make a low carb version. Of course hers were made with oats,white chocolate,sweet cranberries,and sugar. Not good for my diabetes.
Thanks for coming up with fantastic low carb recipes.
Carolyn says
Yes, I am sure they could be made into bars and they would be great with butter instead of coconut oil.
Barbara Bennett says
Caroyln..I hope you can help me..I just made these today with what I believe are the same ingredients as yours..I have followed you long enough to know what they are..I made mine with a scoop, got maybe 21 or so..Flattened them as you suggested..ovens all vary so I start with less time then the recipe..Just to see..They just seemed dry to me, I under cooked a batch to see..not a big difference..Also why do you think my cookies come out so pale..I mean anemic ..Is the Almond Flour, I use Bobs extra fine ..I also never pack the flour..What do u think happened..Thank you..
Carolyn says
Are you using the same sweetener?
Alana says
I want to make these but without the stevia. How much Swerve would I replace the Stevia and erythritol with?
Carolyn says
Replace with another 1/4 cup Swerve.
Alana says
Thank you so much! Making theses and the Italian Christmas Cookies tomorrow. So glad I will be able to have Christmas goodies that I can actually eat this year!
Pam Vienneau says
Using this dough as a base and fresh cranberries, I can redo my favorite holiday cookie…I’ll be using macadamia nuts and SF white chocolate chips (homemade I hope – looking for a recipe)
Aubrey says
Would these work with frozen cranberries? I can’t find unsweetened ones. These look so yummy!
Carolyn says
Yes, they will.
Brenda says
These cookies are wonderful – as good as or better than those with sugar and wheat flour!!!
Misty says
Hi there! Thank you for sharing your recipe. I just came across your website looking for a Copy cat of Jason’s Deli oatmeal cranberry walnut cookie, in low carb form. I just wonder will using almond meal be okay for cookies. I read about the differnce but hoping the mean will work as that is what I have on hand.
Carolyn says
It’s certainly worth a try but you won’t have quite as fine a cookie.
Misty says
Thanks for your fast response. I have them in the oven now. Will let u know how they turn out. Tastes the batter and was really good! Thanks again!
Misty says
Thanks for your fast response. I have them in the oven now. Will let u know how they turn out. Tastes the batter and was really good! Thanks again! Just finished. They were certainly a hit with my Mom and son!! They didn’t come out as pretty as yours but they were delicious!!!!!
Linda says
WOW!
I followed your recipe for making my own dried cranberries (halved the sweetener), as well as your “homemade chocolate chips”. Then, I went to work at stirring up a batch of the above cookies. I used ground xylitol and a little stevia as sweeteners all the way around. My husband (20 yrs w type 2) and I agree that these are the best gf/sf cookies ever. He will watch his sugar levels closely to make sure these darlings do not raise his glucose readings. He is pretty sensitive. He is strict w diet and is only on 1000 mg metformin & 5 mg onglyza daily. No insulin =) Do you have an opinion on the outcome?
Carolyn says
Well of course I have an opinion…my opinion is that I bet they won’t raise his blood sugar much at all and I hope that you will come back and let me know 🙂
Linda says
Well, two batches later, and no noted blood sugar increase. He is so happy =)
By the way, I used the link above for the dried cranberries, the 8 hour version. They are wonderful! And so are you!
Thank you for your dedication to improving the health, and quality of life of diabetics & their families. We are all healthier and happier because of you.
Carolyn says
I am thrilled to hear it! 🙂
sara says
I totally burnt the first batch of these & they still tasted awesome! Thanks for sharing!
Cindy says
Have you tried freezing half the dough and baking at a later date? I’m wondering how to go about that? Form into cookies first or slice them frozen? I’m guessing they would take longer to bake…any thoughts?
Carolyn says
No, I haven’t tried it but my thought would be to form them into cookie first.
heather says
These cookies were, hands down, THE BEST cookies I have ever made with almond flour! The result was tender and even a bit chewy (I mixed grass-fed butter with the unrefined coconut oil for the same amount for a slightly different taste). They are gorgeous to look at and even non-gf eaters loved them. In full disclosure, I did sub sugar for the sugar substitutes (1 tbsp fine cane sugar and 4 tbps brown sugar, regular dried cranberries and regular mini semi-sweet choc chips) but in the scheme of things, that is so much LESS sugar than a “”normal” cookie recipe and they were still perfectly sweet. I am addicted! Thank you for this innovative recipe.
Cindy says
Hi – can’t wait to try these. But, I have every ingredient except for the erythritol. Can I use sucanat, coconut crystals or cane sugar? Thx!
Carolyn says
Yes, i think they would work fine.
Victoria Olson says
I made these today and they came out salty, tasteless and dry. I do pack my almond meal into the measuring cups, maybe that’s why.
I measured out level Tablespoonsful and got 25 cookies, so it’s not that mine were bigger. I flattened them out to 1/2″ height.
I added slightly more ‘extra ingredients’, 1/3 cup each (chopped) instead of 1/4 cup. That seemed more like the right amount.
I would suggest doubling the sweeteners. The cookies came out like crackers. My DH calls them ‘Stalinist cookies’ because they are bereft of sweetness, more like fat crumbly crackers than cookies.
More vanilla extract might help, too.
I HAD to bake them for 20 minutes. At 15 minutes they were still wet in the center, and I didn’t like the underdone mouth feel, because half the cookie was fall-apart crumbly and half was soggy. Maybe more xanthan gum?
Anyway, I think this recipe needs work, sorry. YMMV.
Carolyn says
I am sorry, Victoria, but this recipe does not actually need work, if you make it as written. I’ve made it several times. I do not pack my almond flour…if I did, I would specify that in the recipe. You have come here with your ideas of what constitutes good low carb, gluten-free baking. I have my own very extensive experience and I do things differently. Many other readers have made these and loved them so I know it’s not the basic recipe that is at issue here.
As with much in gluten-free baking, if you do things a little different, the results can vary greatly. You mentioned in another comment that you use a different sweetener. Again, that is a huge part of the issue. Please understand that you are more than welcome to experiment with my recipes. However, unless you follow them to the letter, I cannot guarantee the outcome. That goes without saying, I would think.
heather says
These cookies look amazing! I am excited to try them but I am not a fan of sugar substitutes and would rather just use sugar (or honey) (yes, I know this defeats the “lowcarb” purpose but my purpose is good gf cookie and I am not too concerned with the carbs per se). How would I sub sugar or honey in for the erythritol?
Thanks!!
Carolyn says
Okay, definitely don’t use honey. If sugar, use in the same amount as I use Swerve. If you can get coconut sugar, even better.
heather says
Wow–thanks so much for your prompt reply! And for even addressing what I now realize may be a rude question given the point of the recipe to avoid actual sugar–I am sorry about that! I hope to experiment with these this weekend.
Carolyn says
It didn’t come across as rude at all! Sorry, I am in a bit of a rush this morning so my reply might have been abrupt. Don’t use honey because it will add too much liquid and your wet/dry ratios will be off. You’re much better off with granulated sugar or coconut sugar.
Victoria Olson says
ChocoPerfection brand makes a dark chocolate bar that is sugar free (milk chocolate, too). It must be chopped but melts nicely when heated, stays firm at room temperature, tastes like the real thing and will melt in your mouth. I love it in low carb chocolate chip cookies. It’s available at health food stores. I think the bars are 3 or 4 ounces. ChocoPerfection used to make chips, not any more. Maybe they’ll do so again.
Victoria Olson says
Edit: the bars are 1.78 ounces. This is about 1/3 cup chopped.
Victoria Olson says
I’m a gluten-free, sugar-free baker for almost a year at this writing, who’s used both TJ’s skins-on, and Bob’s Red Mill blanched almond flours. I prefer TJ’s, I like the ‘whole meal’ feel, its dryness and lightness. I think blanched almond flour is too dense and damp for baking, but that’s my opinion. I don’t think one is better than the other, it’s a matter of preference.
I would like to say it’s important to pack a dedicated-amount dry measure cup (1/4, 1/2, 1/3, etc.), with nut meal flour, vs. not packing it down or using a single, multi-amount single-cup wet measure. To not do so, especially with Paleo baking (honey is used), will get you a soggy finished product. TJ’s absorbs moisture better. You may need a Tablespoon or so more TJ’s almond flour than the blanched almond kind in a recipe.
Modern baked goods are based on centuries of experience with sugar and wheat flour. Sugar tenderizes baked goods by pulling in more moisture than the wheat flour (when that’s used), preventing the creation of gluten. Gluten adds density, structure. The presence of sugar means less gluten, thus softer cookies. Sugar in combination with a fat (butter/margarine/shortening) will melt away, leaving spaces in the fat that become filled with CO2 during baking. This adds an ‘airiness’ to the final product. That’s why we ‘cream’ the butter and sugar together, to get that holes-filled-with-CO2 result. Sugar also caramelizes when baked, creating a browner, crispier product with more ‘eye appeal’.
The impact of sugar flies out the window when you don’t use it with wheat flour, or at all, or if you use honey (Paleo), which adds liquid. Without gluten and sugar we’re destined to have spongey cookies. I’m not upset by that.
I don’t care for the taste of Stevia, so I use a Splenda-type (store brand), dry, granulated, no calorie sweetener. I’m very pleased with the results, and appreciate all the pioneering work people like the original poster here are doing to raise awareness of gluten-free, sugar-free baking.
Sue Bender says
Victoria Olsen, I learned a lot from your comment. I never knew before why we cream butter and sugar for example. If you ever do cooking classes or demonstrations online (you-tube) I would be interested in knowing about it! Thanks
Victoria Olson says
Sue – thank you for your kind comment. I do love to bake and the Internet is full of helpful info. Happy baking to you!
Hangga says
Hi victoria thanks for knowledge. i am also baker who specialize in low carbs baked goods. i ve to admit i find it is hard to get crunchy cookies in low carb style, most cookies tend to be soft. i dont hv problem with it, but in my country most ppl love crunchy cookies .