This creamy Sugar-Free Honey Mustard Sauce is nothing short of amazing! Tangy and sweet, it’s the perfect dip or dressing for all your keto veggies, salads, and appetizers. And with less than 1 gram carbs per serving, you will want to put it on everything!
To say that I am obsessed with this keto-friendly honey mustard dressing is the understatement of the year. Absolutely and utterly obsessed. I can’t stop licking the spoon as I drizzle it on everything I can think of.
Historically, honey mustard hasn’t been my favorite flavor of dressing or dip. Typically I am a ranch dressing girl. And I love my chunky feta dressing too.
But this easy recipe has made a convert out of me. I knew I would like it, but I didn’t realize I would like it this much. I eat salad for lunch almost every day now, simply so I can eat more of it.
Whip up a batch of sugar-free honey mustard sauce and let’s get dipping!
How can honey mustard be keto?
If you’ve been keto for a while, you likely know that honey isn’t remotely keto friendly. While it’s often touted as better for you than table sugar, it’s not a good choice for a sugar-free diet.
But I’ve discovered a sweetener that I love that really mimics the flavor and consistency of honey. I find myself reaching for this allulose honey frequently for both sweet and savory recipes.
Swaps for allulose honey
Now, you know I like to make my keto recipes as accessible as possible to everyone. Not everyone has access to allulose honey, so I also tested this recipe with Swerve.
I liked the flavor of the Swerve Brown the best, but it doesn’t blend in as well. In the end, I mixed it with some gently warmed avocado oil until it was mostly dissolved, before I added it to the rest of the ingredients. If you choose this route, use 3 tablespoons of Swerve in 2 tablespoons of oil.
If you can get granular allulose or BochaSweet, you can simply use 4 tablespoons whisk it right into the rest of the ingredients, as it dissolves more readily.
Ingredients
- Mustard – I prefer Dijon in this recipe but yellow mustard works too
- Mayonnaise
- Allulose honey – see above for alternatives
- Apple cider vinegar
- Cayenne
How to make Sugar Free Honey Mustard Dressing
- Whisk all of the ingredients together until smooth.
- That’s it.
Pretty complicated stuff! No, really, it is THAT easy. But if you want to thin it out more for salad dressing, simply add another tablespoon of vinegar and a tablespoon or two of avocado or olive oil.
Frequently Asked Questions
It’s all of the above! Sugar free honey mustard is incredibly versatile. Use it for a dip for veggies or wings, drizzled it over meat as a sauce, or use it for salad dressing.
Yes you can. Please see the section entitled Swaps for allulose honey above. You can really use almost any sweetener here but some are trickier to dissolve and I make suggestions in that section.
Absolutely. This keto dip and dressing has nothing in it that will spoil and will store nicely for several weeks. I recommend keeping it in a glass jar in the fridge.
What to serve with keto honey mustard?
I have been drizzling it over salad almost every day, but it’s good in so many ways as a sauce or a dip. Try it with:
- Cheesy Chicken Fritters
- Keto Meatloaf
- Everything Bagel Pull Apart Bread
- Keto Pretzel Bites
- Keto Meatballs
- Salmon Spinach Salad
- Cheddar Jalapeno Meatballs
Keto Honey Mustard Dressing
Ingredients
- 6 tbsp (83 g) Dijon mustard, or yellow mustard
- 1/3 cup (74.67 g) mayonnaise
- 1/4 cup (84.75 g) allulose honey, See blog post for alternatives!
- 1 tbsp (1 tbsp) apple cider vinegar
- 1/4 tsp (0.25 tsp) cayenne
Instructions
- Add all of the ingredients to a bowl and whisk until smooth. Store in a glass jar in the fridge for up to 3 weeks
- For a thinner sauce or dressing, add an additional tablespoon apple cider vinegar and 1 to 2 tablespoons olive or avocado oil.
Nutrition
Free Bonus: Secrets to Keto Baking!
Sign up for your favorite recipes delivered straight to your inbox plus get our FREE bonus: Secrets to Keto Baking!
I’ve used this recipe many times. I don’t care for cayenne in my dressing, but I add dried Dill and garlic powder for enhanced flavor. Thank you for all your recipes, Carolyn!!
This is a great recipe. Being diabetic I have avoided honey mustard sauce. Nice to have found this. I suggest you look into another simple sauce to make, Jezebel Sauce. I have been making it with sugar-free Apricot and sugar-free Peach preserves. There are many recipes for the regular version on Google.
Awesome flavor!!! I will be making this every week.
Thank you! I really miss honey mustard, so I am super happy to have a keto version that I can whip up easily.
BIG thanks also for providing alternatives to allulose products, because allulose still hasn’t been approved in Canada.
Enjoy!
Delicious! I used Choc Zeros honey. Added the extra tablespoon of vinegar. Great for the green salad served with your pizza (pepperoni) recipe. For dessert your Swerve recipe for Blueberry Breakfast bars. A complete ADIDAF lunch. Thank you for all your great recipes.
i was gonna use swerve brown mixed with the oil in place of honey, but I don’t have avocado oil. will olive oil work in place of avocado?
Sure!
so there’s no oil in it? only add oil if you want to thin it out?
Yes… given that mayo is made from oil and eggs, there is no need for additional oil.
I will have to try this soon! Can I use ChocZero’s honey?
You bet!
Hi Carolyn, I am going to do your sausage bites this NYE for a party and wanted to use this dipping sauce. The allulose honey isn’t available but I have the Nature’s Hollow Honey substitute which uses xylitol as it’s main ingredient. Would this be a good sub for the allulose honey?
Many thanks for all you do for us to keep Keto during the holidays and everyday!
Yup, should be fine!
Allulose honey flavored is no longer available at Amazon. After searching for the company I found out that it’s made China from cornstarch not the natural ingredients that could have been used. Check your info.
It’s not made from cornstarch.. it’s made from a fermentation of corn with microbes. Corn is a natural ingredient, and the fermentation process means that no corn is left in the final product. Similar to the way grain alcohols no longer contain any grain. Additionally, other sweeteners such as erythritol and xylitol are made by similar processes. I know my info very well. Thanks!
Love your recipes, thanks for sharing!
I have liquid Allulose. Do I need to add anything to it -like the Swerve Brown- to get that “honey” flavor, or would the liquid be sufficient?
Sounds delicious!! All I need is some chicken nuggets or tenders now.
This is now a staple at my kitchen. Thanks so much for sharing the recipe!
Yes! I was wanting some honey mustard but didnt have any and this recipe is a game changer! thank you for sharing!
made the honey mustard sauce tonight with the cheesy chicken fritters…
this is now a highly recommended recipe by my carbivore family!!!
we also made the stuffed mushrooms recipe and ate an “appetizer buffet” for dinner 🙂
thanks, carolyn, for all your work making “normal” foods into such wonderful keto/low carb deliciousness!!!
Made it yesterday and couldn’t quit thinking about what to eat with this delicious honey mustard. Leftover salmon, tortilla chips, salads….the list is endless. My favorite go-to dip/dressing from now on. Thank you for your recipes and sharing them all with us. Keep up the excellent work. And thanks for giving substitutions. I used the Swerve brown sugar and it was fantastic!
Same! I am obsessed!
✅!!!Another great recipe added to my repertoire! You always have great low carb recipes that I can count on! Thanks for another tasty one!
So glad you like it! I just had a big salad with it for lunch.
You’re always making me try yet another recipe. This recipe looked so good and I do like honey mustard dressing so I had to try it. Couldn’t wait 1 1/2 hrs for dinner so I’m eating some lettuce now with the delicious honey mustard dressing. This will be a regular in my refrigerator from now on.
Excellent!
I am so glad. I inspired myself to make a new batch today too and had a big salad for lunch!
Made yet another batch today. I love this stuff!
Botha Sweet… Amazon.ca????????… $59.00 a pound! Too crazy for me!
Gladys, Toronto????????
Try looking for it in a local health food store. I have one place in my city that I can buy it – still expensive, but $39 for a 2lb bag. Amazon is not a great place to buy “alternative” products! Now that I know about BochaSweet I cannot do keto without it as it is a total game changer.