Rich Chocolate Yogurt Pops (Low Carb and Gluten-Free)

So I promised you a delicious, Greek yogurt based recipe to go along with last week’s giveaway . This is that recipe, and it really is delicious. It also happens to be quite versatile, and it came about in a rather circuitous fashion, so bear with me. I had recently seen a recipe for dark chocolate frozen yogurt on someone else’s blog and I thought it sounded wonderful, and possibly adaptable for low carb.  But when it came time to make it, I couldn’t remember on who’s blog I’d seen it.  This is typical for me, and I am sorry to the blogger as I can’t give proper credit for the inspiration.  I do know I commented on it, so if this rings a bell to anyone, speak up!  I will happily edit the post to put your link in.

I knew no matter what recipe I adapted, I would have to do some experimentation.  If you are used to working with sweet and semi-sweet chocolate, you may not realize how finicky unsweetened and high % cacao chocolate is.  It’s tricky stuff and as a general rule, it does not like to be added to liquid.  I’ve had more batches of seized chocolate than I care to discuss, quite frankly.  Sometimes, I can unseize the chocolate with a little butter or oil and some brisk stirring.  Sometimes, it can’t be saved.  And I was pretty certain that if I just tried to melt some unsweetened or very dark chocolate and add it to the yogurt, I’d get an inedible mess.  I didn’t want to take that risk.  I decided to melt the chocolate by adding it to hot cream.  Sometimes this ends up with seized chocolate, sometimes it doesn’t.  I am never quite sure what will happen.

Well, it seized.  And I panicked.  I did not want to have to throw out the whole batch.  But I remembered a trick I’d read in Cook’s Illustrated about unseizing chocolate by adding MORE liquid.  Sounds completely counter-intuitive, right?  I sure thought so, but I figured it was worth a try.  I added one tablespoon more cream, increased the heat slightly, and whisked vigorously.  It seemed to start smoothing out, so I added another tablespoon of cream and kept whisking.  And to my surprise, it completely smoothed out.  I was worried it would seize again when I added it to the yogurt, but it mixed in beautifully.

The Results:  The original intention was simply to make frozen yogurt.  But after I’d chilled the mixture, it thickened up remarkably.  It was almost like pudding, quite honestly, and I could hardly help myself but to scoop out a little bowl and eat it just as it was.  It was delicious, rich and chocolatey but with that tang of yogurt.  The texture was smooth and creamy, but as thick as if it was soft-serve frozen yogurt.  I knew it would have been great churned in an ice cream maker, but the thick texture was really appealing just as it was and I contemplated not freezing it at all.  We’ve had this crazy warm spell here and I wanted a frozen treat, so in the end, I opted for spooning it into popsicle molds and freezing it that way.  And I was really, REALLY happy with the results. Trust me, these are the ultimate healthy, warm weather treat.

Rich Chocolate Yogurt Pops
1/2 cup whipping cream**
2 tbsp cocoa powder
1/4 cup powdered erythritol
3.5 oz high % cacao (85% or higher) chocolate, finely chopped
18 oz Greek yogurt
25 drops stevia extract
1/2 tsp vanilla

In a small saucepan over low heat, combine whipping cream, cocoa powder and powdered erythritol, whisking until smooth. Heat through but do not bring to a simmer. Add chopped chocolate and allow to sit 2 minutes, until melted, then whisk until smooth.

**Depending on the chocolate you use, it may seize when added to the hot cream. All you need to do is increase the heat a bit, and add more cream, one tablespoon at a time, whisking vigorously until it smooths out.

In a medium bowl, combine Greek yogurt, stevia and vanilla extracts. Stir in chocolate mixture until well combined. Spoon or pipe into popsicle molds, add sticks and freeze until solid, at least 2 hours.

Alternatively, you can refrigerate the mixture for an hour or two and then churn it in an ice cream maker according to manufacturer’s directions.

Makes 12 small-sized popsicles.  Each popsicle has 4.9 g of carbs and 1.2 g of fiber.  Total NET CARBS = 3.7 g.

For frozen yogurt, it makes about 6 servings.  So double the amounts above for total carbs.

Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...


  1. I don't know where you first saw this either, but I sure am glad you are sharing this version now! These look incredible.

  2. Mmm I'm glad you stuck with it! This looks delicious. My kids are crazy for popsicles in the warm weather so I am constantly making them at home. I love the idea of putting greek yogurt in. I eat greek yogurt evert day but my preschooler prefers regular yogurt. I can be sneaky now eith this yummy recipe…

  3. Healthy pop….now thats a killer

  4. Yum… nearly guilt free :)

  5. See, chocolate's just not worth the headache. :) Kudos to you for pushing through the seized issue and making this recipe work. It does look amazing. When I was a kid I loved fudgsicles.

  6. Last night I made frozen chocolate yogurt! :) But now that I see your recipe, I think I'll have to make some more tonight as well :-P Those pops look really good + I'm actually interested in trying the yogurt even before freezing — looks pretty delicious!

  7. bookmarked! Love these!

  8. I have an instant craving for a pupping pop! Haven't thought of those in years! These look sooooo good…glad the chocolate behaved and you were able to bring it back!

  9. I'm always looking for low carb desserts for my husband. Thank you for these!

  10. spiffycookie says:

    Oo greek yogurt pops, i like it!

  11. Oooh, that looks amazing – creamy and absolutely indulgent :) I've never had frozen Greek yogurt, but I'd love to try!

  12. Having grown up on pudding pops – that's what these remind me of, Definitely on my summer frozen treat list! They look great!

  13. How fun are these chocolate yogurt pops?? Love your photos!

  14. themessybakerblog says:

    I'm going to have to make these. They sound amazing and look delish. Totally saving this recipe. Thanks for sharing!

  15. Oh this is too good!!! What a great recipe and photos are making my mouth water!!! Yummy!!!!

  16. RavieNomNoms says:

    OH WOW, those look absolutely stunning. What a perfect treat for those warm days we were having. Looks soooo yummy.

  17. These are out of this world amazing! I love Cooks Illustrated. I learn so much from them and it's saved many a recipe here in our kitchen.

  18. these yogurt pops are so much fun Carolyn!

  19. These totally remind me of Pudding Pops I had as a kid! But MUCH healthier :) so fun!

  20. Now this is a way I might actually eat Greek Yogurt! Look healthy, and yummy!

  21. Yum! These guys look scrumptious.

  22. What a tasty frozen treat – I know my kids would love these!

  23. stephday says:

    YUM! What a perfect frozen treat!

  24. I`m so glad you were able to save these, they look delicious! Bookmarking this for when it warms up again.

  25. theharriedcook says:

    Okay, I am so totally making these! Summer is setting in here, and these would be perfect! I love that you were able to salvage it! Thanks for sharing :)

  26. I love Greek yogurt pops, and they are so fun, and easy to make! Yours sound DELISH! Hugs, Terra

  27. Sounds so good, Carolyn. Yum! :)

  28. Sylvie @ Gourmande in the Kitchen says:

    Perfect treat for a sunny day!

  29. Hi! I've nominated you for a Versatile Blogger Award! I just love your blog :)
    ” target=”_blank”>

  30. This are fantastic. Forget the kids, where do I sign up.

  31. Summer has arrived in my part of the world and this looks so delicious to chill out during the day. Could you please tell me what can I replace stevia with.. I'm not sure I get that at my place.

  32. I am looking forward to trying this recipe out! Congrats on top 9!

  33. Lora @Cakeduchess says:

    These yogurt pops are perfect for the warmer days you've been having. So much fun to make and so rich from the yogurt:)

  34. These look amazing, and your intense description of them makes me want half a dozen right now! And the weather is not warm here at the moment…

  35. These look amazing!!! Thank you!

  36. food_dreamer says:

    You could just do sugar. That's the only thing I can think to recommend. Or splenda


    Blog: All Day I Dream About Food

  37. food_dreamer says:

    Thank you! I am sorry I didnn't see this earlier…


    Blog: All Day I Dream About Food

  38. Such a good idea, I never thought of making lolly pops!

Speak Your Mind