I had never even heard of Comeback Sauce (aka Mississippi Comeback Sauce) until a few weeks ago. Where the heck have I been? Living under a rock? Very possibly! I was looking up the menu of a restaurant and saw it listed with several dishes. With such a compelling name, I had to look it up. And then I had to make a keto-friendly version!
This sauce is pure flavor magic. I’ve been dipping, drizzling, and dunking my way through it for days on end.
Because so many commercial sauces and dressings have added sugar, I like to make my own. And it usually takes no more effort than whisking the ingredients together in a bowl. That’s why recipes like my Keto BBQ Sauce or Sugar Free Honey Mustard are so beloved by readers.
But this Keto Comeback Sauce is truly something special. It takes any meal to a whole new level. I guarantee you will love it!
Ingredients and Substitutions
- Mayonnaise: This provides the creamy base of the sauce.
- Tomato paste: Comeback sauce typically takes ketchup and/or chili sauce, both of which contain sugar. I use tomato paste plus some sweetener to make up the difference.
- Sweetener: I used allulose honey for this recipe but you could easily use your favorite.
- Apple cider vinegar: Gives the sauce an extra tanginess.
- Worcestershire sauce: Adds a touch of umami.
- Hot sauce: You can add as little or as much as you like. I start off with half a teaspoon and add more to taste.
- Seasonings: Garlic powder, smoked paprika, onion powder, salt, pepper, chipotle powder, and allspice (or ground cloves).
Tips for Success
This delicious Keto Comeback Sauce comes together in a matter of minutes and it’s ready to serve right away. But a few things to keep in mind:
- Whatever sweetener you use should be powdered or liquid to avoid grittiness.
- Worcestershire sauce does contain a little sugar, but the amount used in this recipe makes it almost negligible. 1 gram of carbs per teaspoon spread out over 6 servings means it adds only 0.17 grams. If you need to be gluten-free, choose the Lee and Perrins brand.
- I add a touch of allspice to this recipe because it’s a key seasoning in ketchup (I use it in my keto ketchup recipe as well). You can also use ground cloves, or skip it altogether.
- Once the ingredients are well combined, give it a taste and adjust as you wish. I do recommend waiting a little before you add more hot sauce or chipotle powder, as the heat develops as the sauce sits.
What to Serve with Keto Comeback Sauce
This easy and delicious condiment goes with just about anything you can dream up. It’s wonderful over burgers or grilled chicken. I’ve been enjoying it with…
Keto Comeback Sauce Recipe
Ingredients
- 1/2 cup (112 g) mayonnaise
- 2 tbsp (30 ml) water
- 1 1/2 tbsp (24.35 g) tomato paste
- 1 tbsp (10.14 g) allulose honey, (or other sweetener)
- 1 tbsp (15.22 g) apple cider vinegar
- 1 tsp Worcestershire sauce
- 1/2 tsp hot sauce , I used Tapatio
- 1 tsp granulated garlic
- 1 tsp smoked paprika
- 1/2 tsp onion powder
- 1/2 tsp salt
- 1/2 tsp pepper
- 1/4 tsp chipotle powder, (or 1/2 tsp chili powder)
- 1/8 tsp allspice
Instructions
- Whisk all ingredients together in a medium bowl.
- Taste and adjust seasoning as desired.
Notes
Nutrition
Nutritional Disclaimer
Please note that I am not a medical or nutritional professional. I am simply recounting and sharing my own experiences on this blog. Nothing I express here should be taken as medical advice and you should consult with your doctor before starting any diet or exercise program. I provide nutritional information for my recipes simply as a courtesy to my readers. It is calculated using MacGourmet software and I remove erythritol from the final carb count and net carb count, as it does not affect my own blood glucose levels. I do my best to be as accurate as possible but you should independently calculate nutritional information on your own before relying on them. I expressly disclaim any and all liability of any kind with respect to any act or omission wholly or in part in reliance on anything contained in this website.
Free Bonus: Secrets to Keto Baking!
Sign up for your favorite recipes delivered straight to your inbox plus get our FREE bonus: Secrets to Keto Baking!
Going to try this tomorrow with roasted broc & cauli. Except I’m going to use keto hot honey as I actually splurged & ordered some. Can’t get it here unless ordered from iherb & even then I paid abt $15 on sale! I just think this recipe lends itself to hot honey!!!! Thanks for the great recipe!
now I know why it is called “come back sauce, ” it is delicious. 😋
This is delicious! I topped my salmon with it and cooked it in the air fryer. it was so good. thanks again for all your wonderful recipes.
I look forward to trying this. Thank you.
I just made this sauce and it is incredible! You have another winner with this recipe!! So tasty and pairs well with grilled meats and veggies. Thank you for your fantastic recipes!
Thank you!
This sounds great, I make a chipotle mayo sauce that is similar and wouldn’t you know that Tabasco makes a chipotle flavor? Lol, try it on zucchini fries. I’ll make this one and compare it. Carolyn thank you for all you do.
this sauce is amazing. Not too spicy but has a nice kick. I will definitely be keeping this on hand for dipping all the things.
Made it an hour ago. Looked interesting and creative. It is delicious and I put a little extra chipotle because I like a little kick. I’m serving it tonight with some peel and eat shrimp. Normally I make keto bang bang sauce but this recipe is every bit as good. Thanks!
Great to hear! I loved it too… I was dipping meatballs and roasted cauliflower, and drizzling it over grilled chicken.
This is such a flavorful sauce!
But def. let it sit before you add more heat, or it might become too hot
I found stevia sweetened Heinz Ketchup at my Walmart here in the mountains of NW GA!!! Love it!!! 🥰❤️😘😍
I’m going to make this today and serve it tonight. Thank you.